Trellis is hiring engineers to build AI-powered tools specifically designed for working with PDFs. They aim to create the best AI agents for interacting with and manipulating PDF documents, streamlining tasks like data extraction, analysis, and form completion. The company is backed by Y Combinator and emphasizes a fast-paced, innovative environment.
Trellis is a YC-backed startup building a platform to simplify and automate legal processes for startups, initially focusing on Delaware incorporations. They aim to make legal tasks like forming a company, issuing stock options, and managing cap tables as easy as possible, reducing the time and cost typically associated with these processes. Trellis is currently hiring engineers and designers to join their team.
Commenters on Hacker News express skepticism about the value proposition of Trellis, questioning whether automating social media for local businesses is truly a significant pain point. Some argue that the cost likely outweighs the benefits for small businesses, especially given existing free or low-cost scheduling tools. Others point out the difficulty in creating engaging, authentic social media content automatically, suggesting that genuine interaction is more effective than automated posts. The limited customization options within Trellis are also criticized. A few commenters offer alternative solutions like Buffer or Hootsuite, implying that Trellis doesn't offer enough differentiation to justify its existence. Finally, several commenters note the potential for abuse and spam if the platform isn't carefully managed.
Summary of Comments ( 0 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43253463
HN commenters express skepticism about the feasibility of creating truly useful AI agents for PDFs, particularly given the varied and complex nature of PDF data. Some question the value proposition, suggesting existing tools and techniques already adequately address common PDF-related tasks. Others are concerned about potential hallucination issues and the difficulty of verifying AI-generated output derived from PDFs. However, some commenters express interest in the potential applications, particularly in niche areas like legal or financial document analysis, if accuracy and reliability can be assured. The discussion also touches on the technical challenges involved, including OCR limitations and the need for robust semantic understanding of document content. Several commenters mention alternative approaches, like vector databases, as potentially more suitable for this problem domain.
The Hacker News post discussing Trellis, a YC W24 company hiring engineers to build AI agents for PDFs, has a modest number of comments, focusing primarily on the practical applications and potential challenges of the technology.
Several commenters express interest in the specific use cases. One user questions how Trellis handles situations where the desired information isn't explicitly stated in the PDF, but requires inference or external knowledge. They provide the example of extracting the manufacturing location of a product, which might not be directly stated but could be inferred from other details. Another user highlights the potential for tools like Trellis to automate tasks like filling out PDF forms, which is a common pain point. They also suggest integrating with existing document management systems.
Another thread discusses the challenges of accurately extracting information from the diverse and often messy world of PDFs. One commenter points out the difficulty of dealing with scanned PDFs, which are essentially images, and how OCR (Optical Character Recognition) can introduce errors. They also mention the variability in PDF formatting, making it difficult to create a one-size-fits-all solution. This leads to a discussion about the technical approaches Trellis might be using, with speculation around techniques like layout analysis and transformer models.
Some commenters express skepticism about the long-term viability of focusing solely on PDFs, suggesting that the ideal solution would handle various document formats. They also question the defensibility of the technology, wondering if larger players with more resources could easily replicate it.
Finally, a few comments touch on the hiring aspect of the post, with some users inquiring about the specific tech stack and engineering challenges at Trellis. One user humorously suggests the need for "PDF whisperers" given the complexities of working with the format.
Overall, the comments reflect a mix of excitement about the potential of AI-powered PDF analysis, pragmatic concerns about the technical hurdles, and curiosity about the specific implementation details of Trellis's approach. They highlight the need for robust solutions that can handle the complexities of real-world PDFs and integrate seamlessly into existing workflows.