Foundry, a YC-backed startup, is seeking a founding engineer to build a massive web crawler. This engineer will be instrumental in designing and implementing a highly scalable and robust crawling infrastructure, tackling challenges like data extraction, parsing, and storage. Ideal candidates possess strong experience with distributed systems, web scraping technologies, and handling terabytes of data. This is a unique opportunity to shape the foundation of a company aiming to index and organize the internet's publicly accessible information.
TSMC is reportedly in talks with Intel to potentially manufacture chips for Intel's GPU division using TSMC's advanced 3nm process. This presents a dilemma for TSMC, as accepting Intel's business would mean allocating valuable 3nm capacity away from existing customers like Apple and Nvidia, potentially impacting their product roadmaps. Further complicating matters is the geopolitical pressure TSMC faces to reduce its reliance on China, with the US CHIPS Act incentivizing domestic production. While taking on Intel's business could strengthen TSMC's US presence and potentially secure government subsidies, it risks alienating key clients and diverting resources from crucial internal development. TSMC must carefully weigh the benefits of this collaboration against the potential disruption to its existing business and long-term strategic goals.
Hacker News commenters discuss the potential TSMC-Intel collaboration with skepticism. Several doubt Intel's ability to successfully utilize TSMC's advanced nodes, citing Intel's past manufacturing struggles and the potential complexity of integrating different process technologies. Others question the strategic logic for both companies, suggesting that such a partnership could create conflicts of interest and potentially compromise TSMC's competitive advantage. Some commenters also point out the geopolitical implications, noting the US government's desire to strengthen domestic chip production and reduce reliance on Taiwan. A few express concerns about the potential impact on TSMC's capacity and the availability of advanced nodes for other clients. Overall, the sentiment leans towards cautious pessimism about the rumored collaboration.
According to Morris Chang, founding chairman of TSMC, Apple CEO Tim Cook expressed skepticism about Intel's foundry ambitions, reportedly stating that Intel "didn't know how to be a foundry." This comment, made during a meeting where Chang was trying to convince Cook to let Intel manufacture Apple chips, highlights the perceived difference in expertise and experience between established foundry giant TSMC and Intel's relatively nascent efforts in the contract chip manufacturing business. Chang ultimately declined Intel's offer, citing their high prices and lack of a true commitment to being a foundry partner.
Hacker News commenters generally agree with the assessment that Intel struggles with the foundry business model. Several point out the inherent conflict of interest in competing with your own customers, a challenge Intel faces. Some highlight Intel's history of prioritizing its own products over foundry customers, leading to delays and capacity issues for those clients. Others suggest that Intel's internal culture and organizational structure aren't conducive to the customer-centric approach required for a successful foundry. A few express skepticism about the veracity of the quote attributed to Tim Cook, while others suggest it's simply a restatement of widely understood industry realities. Some also discuss the broader geopolitical implications of TSMC's dominance and the US government's efforts to bolster domestic chip manufacturing.
Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co (TSMC) has started producing 4-nanometer chips at its Arizona facility. US Commerce Secretary Gina Raimondo announced the milestone, stating the chips will be ready for customers in 2025. This marks a significant step for US chip production, bringing advanced semiconductor manufacturing capabilities to American soil. While the Arizona plant initially focused on 5-nanometer chips, this shift to 4-nanometer production signifies an upgrade to a more advanced and efficient process.
Hacker News commenters discuss the geopolitical implications of TSMC's Arizona fab, expressing skepticism about its competitiveness with Taiwanese facilities. Some doubt the US can replicate the supporting infrastructure and skilled workforce that TSMC enjoys in Taiwan, potentially leading to higher costs and lower yields. Others highlight the strategic importance of domestic chip production for the US, even if it's less efficient, to reduce reliance on Taiwan amidst rising tensions with China. Several commenters also question the long-term viability of the project given the rapid pace of semiconductor technology advancement, speculating that the Arizona fab may be obsolete by the time it reaches full production. Finally, some express concern about the environmental impact of chip manufacturing, particularly water usage in Arizona's arid climate.
Summary of Comments ( 0 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43257268
Several commenters on Hacker News expressed skepticism and concern regarding the legality and ethics of building an "internet-scale web crawler." Some questioned the feasibility of respecting robots.txt and avoiding legal trouble while operating at such a large scale, suggesting the project would inevitably run afoul of website terms of service. Others discussed technical challenges, like handling rate limiting and the complexities of parsing diverse web content. A few commenters questioned Foundry's business model, speculating about potential uses for the scraped data and expressing unease about the potential for misuse. Some were interested in the technical challenges and saw the job as an intriguing opportunity. Finally, several commenters debated the definition of "internet-scale," with some arguing that truly crawling the entire internet is practically impossible.
The Hacker News post discussing Foundry's job posting for a Founding Engineer to build an internet-scale web crawler generated several comments, mostly focusing on the technical challenges and ethical considerations of such a project.
Several commenters discussed the complexities of building a web crawler at this scale. One commenter highlighted the importance of handling rate limiting, respecting robots.txt, and managing the massive data influx. They pointed out the difficulty of parsing different website structures and the need for robust error handling. Another user emphasized the engineering challenges related to distributed crawling, data deduplication, and efficient storage. The conversation touched upon the need for expertise in technologies like Scrapy, Selenium, and distributed processing frameworks. One comment specifically mentioned the importance of understanding and adhering to legal and ethical guidelines when scraping data.
The ethical implications of large-scale web scraping were also a recurring theme. Some users expressed concerns about potential misuse of scraped data and the privacy implications of collecting vast amounts of information from the web. One comment specifically questioned the company's plans for handling personally identifiable information (PII) and complying with data privacy regulations like GDPR. Another commenter raised the question of the environmental impact of running such a large-scale operation, pointing to the significant energy consumption required for data centers and network infrastructure.
One commenter questioned the "founding engineer" title, suggesting it might indicate a lack of clear direction for the project. They speculated that the company might be experimenting with different ideas, implying a higher degree of risk for the engineer joining at this stage.
Another comment pointed out the potential competitive landscape, suggesting that Foundry might face competition from established players in the web scraping and data aggregation space. They questioned the feasibility of building a truly differentiated offering in a market already dominated by large companies.
Finally, a few comments touched upon the potential benefits of such a project, including the ability to gather valuable data for research, market analysis, and other purposes. However, these comments were generally less detailed and focused more on the hypothetical applications of the technology rather than the specific challenges of building it.