Driven by a lifelong fascination with pipe organs, Martin Wandel embarked on a multi-decade project to build one in his home. Starting with simple PVC pipes and evolving to meticulously crafted wooden ones, he documented his journey of learning woodworking, electronics, and organ-building principles. The project involved designing and constructing the windchest, pipes, keyboard, and the complex electronic control system needed to operate the organ. Over time, Wandel refined his techniques, improving the organ's sound and expanding its capabilities. The result is a testament to his dedication and ingenuity, a fully functional pipe organ built from scratch in his own basement.
The charango, a small, high-pitched Andean stringed instrument, boasts a rich and complex history interwoven with colonialism and Indigenous resilience. Originally crafted using armadillo shells, its unique sound became a symbol of Andean identity. While the transition to wood helped preserve armadillo populations, it also sparked debate surrounding authenticity and tradition. The charango's journey reflects not only the evolution of music but also the enduring legacy of cultural adaptation and the ongoing struggle to preserve heritage in the face of changing times.
HN commenters largely enjoyed the article about the charango, calling it "beautiful" and "well-written." Several discussed their own experiences with the instrument, with one sharing their preference for the Ronroco style. Some comments focused on the technical aspects, questioning the tuning described in the article and debating the historical origins of the instrument's shape. The idea of a hybrid armadillo-wood instrument sparked particular interest, with some expressing skepticism about its resonance and others simply finding it intriguing. The potential connection between the charango and the vihuela was also a point of discussion. A few commenters expressed broader appreciation for learning about unfamiliar musical traditions.
Summary of Comments ( 39 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42831969
Commenters on Hacker News largely expressed admiration for the author's dedication and the impressive feat of building a pipe organ at home. Several appreciated the detailed documentation and the clear passion behind the project. Some discussed the complexities of organ building, touching on topics like voicing pipes and the intricacies of the mechanical action. A few shared personal experiences with organs or other complex DIY projects. One commenter highlighted the author's use of readily available materials, making the project seem more approachable. Another noted the satisfaction derived from such long-term, challenging endeavors. The overall sentiment was one of respect and appreciation for the author's craftsmanship and perseverance.
The Hacker News post titled "The story of my home made pipe organ" (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42831969) links to a personal website detailing an individual's journey in building a pipe organ in their home. The comments section contains a lively discussion with several interesting points.
One commenter highlights the dedication and time investment involved in such a project, expressing admiration for the author's persistence over two decades. They also appreciate the detailed documentation, providing insight into the challenges and solutions encountered throughout the build.
Another commenter focuses on the organ's aesthetic qualities, describing it as a beautiful instrument. They mention the unique visual appeal of the exposed pipes and woodwork, contrasting it with the more enclosed design of traditional church organs. This comment also touches upon the emotional impact of the organ's sound, evoking a sense of awe and grandeur.
A technically-inclined commenter delves into the complexities of organ building, pointing out the intricate mechanisms involved in producing different sounds. They discuss the various types of pipes used, such as flue pipes and reed pipes, and how they contribute to the overall tonal palette. This comment also mentions the challenges of tuning and maintaining such a complex instrument.
Further discussion revolves around the choice of materials used in the organ's construction. One commenter inquires about the type of wood used for the pipes, prompting the original poster (OP) to respond with a detailed explanation of the selection process. The OP clarifies the reasons for choosing specific woods based on their acoustic properties and durability.
Several comments express a general appreciation for the project, acknowledging the skill and craftsmanship required to build a musical instrument of this magnitude. Some commenters also share their personal experiences with organs and organ music, adding a personal touch to the discussion. Finally, a few commenters express curiosity about the organ's sound, suggesting that the OP share audio or video recordings.