Kezurou-kai #39 showcases a variety of traditional Japanese woodworking tools, primarily planes (kanna), being sharpened and used. The post highlights the meticulous process of sharpening these tools, emphasizing the importance of a flat back and a keen edge for achieving clean, precise cuts. It also briefly touches on the use of natural sharpening stones and the skill involved in maintaining these tools, illustrating the deep connection between craftsman and tool in Japanese woodworking.
Sovereign Lumber advocates for a shift in the lumber industry towards localized, small-scale sawmills using sustainably harvested wood. The author argues that current lumber practices, reliant on large-scale operations and often unsustainable forestry, create economic fragility and environmental damage. By promoting smaller mills closer to the source of timber, communities can regain control over their lumber supply, create local jobs, and ensure more responsible forest management. This decentralized approach offers a path to greater resilience and economic independence, while fostering healthier forests and reducing transportation costs and carbon emissions.
Hacker News commenters generally expressed appreciation for the Sovereign Lumber project and its ethos. Several praised the detailed documentation and transparency, finding it refreshing and inspiring. Some questioned the long-term viability and scalability, particularly around sourcing enough appropriate logs and the potential environmental impact. Others discussed the potential for automation and the trade-offs between traditional craftsmanship and modern manufacturing techniques. The high price point was also a topic of discussion, with some arguing that it reflects the true cost of sustainable, locally sourced lumber, while others felt it limited accessibility. A few commenters shared personal anecdotes about woodworking and the challenges of finding high-quality lumber.
Ebenezer Clifford, a 19th-century planemaker in Maine, supplemented his income by diving for shipwrecks. He used a diving suit of his own design, featuring a helmet with a glass faceplate and a flexible hose supplying air from the surface. Clifford’s diving exploits, recovering items like anchors and cannons, were well-known locally. He apparently applied his ingenuity to both planemaking and diving, showcasing a remarkable combination of craftsmanship and adventurous spirit.
Hacker News users discussed the intriguing story of Ebenezer Clifford, a planemaker and diving bell inventor. Several commenters focused on the ingenuity of Clifford's diving bell design, particularly its use of a weighted bellows system for air replenishment. Some debated the historical accuracy of attributing the invention solely to Clifford, pointing to earlier diving bell iterations. Others expressed fascination with Clifford's dual professions and the potential connection between woodworking precision and the technical demands of underwater exploration. A few users shared additional resources about early diving technology, highlighting the dangers and limitations of these pioneering devices. The overall sentiment was one of admiration for Clifford's ingenuity and the historical context of his inventions.
Driven by a lifelong fascination with pipe organs, Martin Wandel embarked on a multi-decade project to build one in his home. Starting with simple PVC pipes and evolving to meticulously crafted wooden ones, he documented his journey of learning woodworking, electronics, and organ-building principles. The project involved designing and constructing the windchest, pipes, keyboard, and the complex electronic control system needed to operate the organ. Over time, Wandel refined his techniques, improving the organ's sound and expanding its capabilities. The result is a testament to his dedication and ingenuity, a fully functional pipe organ built from scratch in his own basement.
Commenters on Hacker News largely expressed admiration for the author's dedication and the impressive feat of building a pipe organ at home. Several appreciated the detailed documentation and the clear passion behind the project. Some discussed the complexities of organ building, touching on topics like voicing pipes and the intricacies of the mechanical action. A few shared personal experiences with organs or other complex DIY projects. One commenter highlighted the author's use of readily available materials, making the project seem more approachable. Another noted the satisfaction derived from such long-term, challenging endeavors. The overall sentiment was one of respect and appreciation for the author's craftsmanship and perseverance.
Jens Quistgaard, a renowned Danish designer, created a series of iconic peppermills characterized by their unique combination of form and function. These mills, produced primarily from the 1960s to the 1980s, feature a distinctive shape, typically made of teak and featuring a ceramic grinding mechanism. Quistgaard prioritized simplicity and craftsmanship, resulting in mills that are both aesthetically pleasing and practical. While variations exist in size, wood type, and base design, they all share a common design language that makes them instantly recognizable as Quistgaard creations. The peppermills are highly collectible today, appreciated for their enduring design and Quistgaard's legacy.
Hacker News users discuss Quistgaard's pepper mills with a mix of appreciation and pragmatism. Several praise the iconic design and craftsmanship, noting their durability and the satisfying grinding mechanism. Others question the practicality, citing issues with refilling, the coarseness of the grind, and the tendency for peppercorns to get stuck. Some commenters share personal anecdotes of owning or inheriting these mills, highlighting their longevity. A few delve into the history of Dansk Designs and Quistgaard's broader work. Overall, the comments reflect a respect for the design while acknowledging its functional limitations. There's also some discussion about the high prices these mills command, with some arguing they are more collectible than practical.
Summary of Comments ( 19 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43679004
HN users largely expressed appreciation for the Kezurou-Kai videos and the craftsmanship they showcase. Several commenters highlighted the meditative and ASMR-like quality of the videos, finding them relaxing and enjoyable to watch. Some discussed the specific tools and techniques used, with one user pointing out the unique plane and its blade sharpening process. The lack of narration and focus on the sounds of woodworking was also praised. A few users mentioned the potential copyright issues surrounding the use of copyrighted music. Overall, the sentiment was positive, with many expressing admiration for the skill and artistry displayed.
The Hacker News post "Kezurou-Kai #39" has generated a moderate number of comments, primarily focusing on the impressive craftsmanship displayed in the woodworking projects showcased in the linked blog post. Several commenters express admiration for the skill and dedication required to produce such high-quality work, often using words like "stunning," "beautiful," and "inspiring."
One recurring theme is the appreciation for the Japanese woodworking tradition and the philosophy of "Kezurou-kai," which emphasizes continuous improvement and sharing of knowledge. Commenters discuss the importance of mentorship and the value of learning from experienced craftspeople, noting how this tradition fosters a culture of excellence.
Some comments delve into specific aspects of the woodworking projects, such as the joinery techniques, tool selection, and finishing processes. These comments often involve a degree of technical discussion, demonstrating a deep understanding of woodworking principles. For example, one commenter points out the precision and cleanliness of the dovetail joints, while another discusses the use of hand tools versus power tools.
There's also a thread discussing the cultural significance of these crafts and the contrast between traditional Japanese woodworking and modern approaches. One commenter reflects on the meditative aspect of hand-tool woodworking, suggesting that it offers a connection to the material and a sense of accomplishment that's often missing in mass-produced items.
Several commenters express a desire to learn more about Japanese woodworking techniques and tools, with some inquiring about resources and learning opportunities. This indicates a genuine interest in the craft and a willingness to explore its intricacies.
Finally, some comments simply express awe and appreciation for the beauty of the finished pieces, highlighting the aesthetic appeal of handcrafted objects. These comments underscore the emotional impact of fine woodworking and the enduring appeal of traditional craftsmanship. The overall sentiment in the comments is one of respect and admiration for the skill and dedication of the Kezurou-kai woodworkers.