The Unix Magic Poster provides a visual guide to essential Unix commands, organized by category and interconnected to illustrate their relationships. It covers file and directory manipulation, process management, text processing, networking, and system information retrieval, aiming to be a quick reference for both beginners and experienced users. The poster emphasizes practical usage by showcasing common command combinations and options, effectively demonstrating how to accomplish various tasks on a Unix-like system. Its interconnectedness highlights the composability and modularity that are central to the Unix philosophy, encouraging users to combine simple commands into powerful workflows.
The Discworld, a flat disc carried on the backs of four elephants standing on a giant turtle, operates on narrative causality rather than strict physics. Things happen because the story requires them to, allowing for both humorous and poignant explorations of human nature and society. Magic is real, but unpredictable and often tied to belief, while the conventional laws of science are frequently bent or broken. This unique setting allows Pratchett to satirize everything from fantasy tropes and political structures to philosophy and the nature of belief itself, creating a world that is both absurd and deeply insightful.
The Hacker News comments on "Discworld Rules" largely praise Venkatesh Rao's insightful distillation of Pratchett's narrative style. Several commenters highlight the "rules" about how magic works, specifically the idea of narrative causality and how belief shapes reality on the Discworld. The observation that Discworld satirizes existing tropes and cliches while simultaneously using them effectively also resonated. Some discussion revolved around how these "rules" apply to other fictional worlds and real-world phenomena like religion and politics. A few commenters mentioned their favorite Discworld books and characters, adding a personal touch to the appreciation for Rao's analysis. One commenter aptly summarized the essence of the Discworld as "reality is a negotiable construct."
Summary of Comments ( 15 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43589042
Commenters on Hacker News largely praised the Unix Magic poster and its annotated version, finding it both nostalgic and informative. Several shared personal anecdotes about their early experiences with Unix and how resources like this poster were invaluable learning tools. Some pointed out specific commands or sections they found particularly useful or interesting, like the explanation of
tee
or the history of different shells. A few commenters offered minor corrections or suggestions for improvement, such as adding more context around certain commands or expanding on the networking section. Overall, the sentiment was overwhelmingly positive, with many expressing appreciation for the effort put into creating and annotating the poster.The Hacker News post "Annotated Unix Magic Poster" with the ID 43589042 has generated several comments discussing the poster and its utility.
Several commenters express nostalgia and appreciation for the original poster, recalling its presence in their early days of learning Unix. They discuss how helpful it was as a quick reference and how it aided in memorizing common commands. One commenter fondly remembers having a laminated copy hanging above their workstation.
A key point of discussion revolves around the poster's relevance in modern computing. While some argue its usefulness has diminished due to improved documentation and readily available online resources, others maintain its value as a concise overview of essential Unix commands. They highlight the benefit of having a physical, readily visible reference that doesn't require searching through documentation. The speed and ease of glancing at the poster for common commands is cited as a major advantage.
Some comments delve into specific commands and their usage, often sparked by the annotations on the poster. There are explanations of less common flags and discussions about the most efficient ways to use particular commands. For example, one commenter elaborates on the different uses of
grep
and discusses its power when combined with regular expressions.A few commenters express a desire for an updated version of the poster, incorporating more modern tools and commands, or perhaps tailored for different operating systems. They discuss what potential additions or changes would be beneficial, including suggestions for tools like
find
,awk
, andsed
.Overall, the comments reflect a mixture of nostalgia for a classic Unix tool and a debate on its continued relevance. While acknowledging the advances in online resources, many commenters still see value in the poster's concise and easily accessible format, emphasizing the speed and convenience it offers for frequent Unix command users. The discussion also extends to potential improvements and updates, showcasing a desire to maintain the spirit of the poster while adapting it to the evolving landscape of Unix-like systems.