A new jailbreak called "WinterBreak" has been released, exploiting a vulnerability present in all currently supported Kindle e-readers. This jailbreak allows users to install custom firmware and software, opening up possibilities like alternative ebook stores, custom fonts, and other enhancements not officially supported by Amazon. The exploit is reliable and relatively easy to execute, requiring only a specially crafted MOBI file to be sideloaded onto the device. This marks a significant development in the Kindle modding community, as previous jailbreaks were often device-specific and quickly patched by Amazon. Users are encouraged to update to the latest Kindle firmware before applying the jailbreak, as WinterBreak supports all current versions.
Bookshop.org, the online platform supporting independent bookstores, has launched its own e-book store and reading app, offering a direct competitor to Amazon's Kindle ecosystem. This allows customers to purchase e-books while still financially supporting their chosen local bookstore. The app provides basic e-reader functionality, including customizable fonts and backgrounds, and purchases are fulfilled by Ingram Content Group, a major book distributor. Bookshop.org aims to provide an ethical alternative for digitally-minded readers who want to support local businesses.
Hacker News commenters generally expressed skepticism about Bookshop.org's e-reader and ebook app. Several questioned its viability against the entrenched Amazon Kindle ecosystem, citing the lack of device integration and limited ebook selection. Some doubted the profitability for independent bookstores, given the small percentage they receive per sale. Others pointed to existing alternatives like Kobo and library ebook programs. A few commenters were more positive, viewing the move as a principled stand against Amazon, but even they acknowledged the uphill battle Bookshop.org faces. There was also discussion of the technical challenges involved in DRM and ebook formats, with some suggesting an open platform would be more appealing. The overall sentiment seemed to be that while the initiative is laudable, its success is far from guaranteed.
Summary of Comments ( 298 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43073969
Hacker News users discuss the implications of a new Kindle jailbreak, primarily focusing on its potential benefits for accessibility and user control. Some express excitement about features like custom fonts, improved PDF handling, and removing Amazon's advertisements. Others caution about potential downsides, such as voiding the warranty and the possibility of bricking the device. A few users share their past experiences with jailbreaking Kindles, mentioning the benefits they've enjoyed, while others question the long-term practicality and the risk versus reward, especially given the relatively low cost of newer Kindles. Several commenters express concern about Amazon's potential response and the future of jailbreaking Kindles.
The Hacker News post titled "All Kindles can now be jailbroken" (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43073969) attracted a moderate number of comments, mostly focusing on the practical implications and ethical considerations of jailbreaking Kindles.
Several commenters discussed the benefits of jailbreaking, such as removing Amazon's restrictions and enabling customization. One user highlighted the ability to run custom screensavers, install alternative reading software like KOReader, and achieve greater control over the device. Another pointed out the advantage of using a jailbroken Kindle with a library management system like Calibre. The ability to sideload books from sources other than Amazon was also mentioned as a key motivator for jailbreaking.
Some users expressed concerns about the potential downsides. One commenter questioned the safety and stability of a jailbroken device, particularly concerning software updates. Another user cautioned about the potential for bricking the device if the jailbreaking process isn't followed correctly.
The discussion also touched on the ethical dimension of jailbreaking. One commenter argued that jailbreaking is justified as a way to reclaim ownership of a device that has been artificially locked down by the manufacturer. This sentiment was echoed by others who felt that consumers should have the right to control the software on their devices. However, another commenter raised the issue of potentially violating Amazon's terms of service and the possible consequences, although the practical enforcement of such terms in this context wasn't thoroughly explored.
A few commenters shared their personal experiences with jailbreaking Kindles, offering practical tips and advice. One user mentioned the ease of the process with the new jailbreak method, while another emphasized the importance of following the instructions carefully to avoid problems.
A couple of users brought up alternative e-readers, like those using e-ink and running Android, suggesting these might be a better option for users seeking greater flexibility and customization without the risks associated with jailbreaking.
Overall, the comments reflect a mixture of enthusiasm for the possibilities offered by jailbreaking, cautious concern about potential risks, and a nuanced discussion about the ethics of circumventing manufacturer restrictions. The most compelling comments are those that balance the potential benefits with the potential drawbacks, offering a realistic perspective on the implications of jailbreaking a Kindle.