In Norway, the traditional practice of harvesting ice from pristine lakes for cocktails is experiencing a resurgence. Driven by a desire for purity and a unique connection to nature, bartenders are seeking out this naturally formed, crystal-clear ice. The slow freezing process in these unpolluted lakes results in dense, highly oxygenated ice that melts slower than commercially produced ice, preserving the integrity of delicate cocktails. This revival not only elevates the cocktail experience but also connects modern mixology with a piece of Norwegian cultural heritage.
The New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) is establishing a new trading floor in Arlington, Texas, called NYSE Texas. Scheduled to open in 2027, this facility will serve as a disaster recovery and backup site for the NYSE's existing operations. It will also house a physical trading floor mirroring the iconic NYSE in New York City, offering a venue for in-person trading and important corporate events like IPO ceremonies. This expansion aims to increase the exchange's resiliency and geographical diversity.
Hacker News commenters were generally cynical about the announcement of NYSE Texas. Many saw it as a thinly veiled attempt to circumvent regulations, potentially relating to taxes or data sovereignty, with some speculating about connections to Texas's lax regulatory environment. Several pointed out the irony of a New York institution establishing a Texas branch for supposed advantages, while others questioned the practical implications and whether any significant trading activity would actually relocate. Some suggested the move was more about optics and public relations than genuine operational needs, especially given the existing electronic nature of trading. A few commenters expressed curiosity about the specifics of the "cutting edge financial technology" mentioned in the press release, but overall the sentiment was skeptical.
Summary of Comments ( 41 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43059779
HN commenters are largely unimpressed with the "lake-harvested" ice, questioning its purity given potential agricultural runoff and other pollutants in a lake versus purpose-made ice. Several commenters point out the historical context of ice harvesting before refrigeration, highlighting that it was a necessity, not a mark of quality. Some suggest the romanticized notion of natural ice is misplaced, preferring the reliability and cleanliness of modern ice production. The purported clarity of the lake ice is also disputed, with some commenters arguing that properly made clear ice at home or in a commercial setting is superior. A few commenters note the environmental impact of transporting the heavy ice, offsetting any perceived benefit.
The Hacker News post titled "In Norway, Lake-Harvested Cocktail Ice Is Making a Quiet Comeback" has generated several comments discussing various aspects of ice harvesting, both historically and in the modern context.
Several commenters focus on the purity and clarity of naturally harvested ice. One user highlights the low mineral content of such ice, contrasting it with the impurities found in standard freezer ice, and suggesting this results in a slower melt and less dilution of drinks. Another commenter reminisces about the exceptionally clear ice harvested from a local lake during their childhood, emphasizing its superior quality compared to manufactured ice. This theme of purity is echoed by another user who recounts the practice of insulating harvested ice with sawdust for year-round use, emphasizing the historical significance of this method.
The discussion also touches upon the environmental impact of ice harvesting. One commenter questions the ecological consequences of large-scale harvesting on lake ecosystems, specifically mentioning potential disruptions to aquatic life. This concern prompts another user to speculate about the scale of modern harvesting operations compared to historical practices, noting the potential difference in impact.
The practicalities of ice harvesting are also considered. One commenter notes the traditional use of large handsaws and horses for cutting and transporting the ice, painting a picture of the labor-intensive process involved. Expanding on this historical context, another user explains the role of specific tools, such as ice saws and tongs, and mentions the community effort often associated with traditional harvesting.
One commenter highlights the cultural aspect, mentioning a Norwegian documentary about "Gutten og Isen" (The Boy and the Ice), which explores the practice of ice harvesting and its significance in certain communities. This cultural perspective is further enriched by a comment linking to a book excerpt describing the historical use of ice houses in Norway ("is-hus" or "ishus").
Finally, some comments offer humorous takes on the topic. One user jokingly suggests starting an ice-exporting business from Norway, while another quips about the possibility of finding frozen Vikings within the harvested ice.
In summary, the comments on the Hacker News post delve into the historical, practical, environmental, and cultural dimensions of lake-harvested ice, offering a multi-faceted perspective on the practice. The comments range from technical explanations of the process to personal anecdotes and humorous observations, reflecting the diverse interests of the Hacker News community.