Marco Cantu's blog post celebrates Delphi's 30th anniversary, reflecting on its enduring relevance in the software development world. He highlights Delphi's initial groundbreaking impact with its rapid application development (RAD) approach and visual component library, emphasizing its evolution over three decades to encompass cross-platform development, mobile, and now, even web and Linux. Cantu acknowledges challenges and missteps along the way but underscores Delphi's resilience and continued commitment to providing developers with robust and productive tools. He concludes by looking forward to the future of Delphi, anticipating further innovations and its ongoing contribution to the software landscape.
Tracebit, a system monitoring tool, is built with C# primarily due to its performance characteristics, especially with regards to garbage collection. While other languages like Go and Rust offer memory management advantages, C#'s generational garbage collector and allocation patterns align well with Tracebit's workload, which involves short-lived objects. This allows for efficient memory management without the complexities of manual control. Additionally, the mature .NET ecosystem, cross-platform compatibility offered by .NET, and the team's existing C# expertise contributed to the decision. Ultimately, C# provided a balance of performance, productivity, and platform support suitable for Tracebit's needs.
Hacker News users discussed the surprising choice of C# for Tracebit, a performance-sensitive tracing tool. Several commenters questioned the rationale, citing potential performance drawbacks compared to C/C++. The author defended the choice, highlighting C#'s developer productivity, rich ecosystem (especially concerning UI development), and the performance benefits of using native libraries for the performance-critical parts. Some users agreed, pointing out the maturity of the .NET ecosystem and the relative ease of finding C# developers. Others remained skeptical, emphasizing the overhead of the .NET runtime and garbage collection. The discussion also touched upon cross-platform compatibility, with commenters acknowledging .NET's improvements in this area but still noting some limitations, particularly regarding native dependencies. A few users shared their positive experiences with C# in performance-sensitive contexts, further fueling the debate.
Summary of Comments ( 36 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43051598
Hacker News users discuss Delphi's 30th anniversary, acknowledging its past dominance and questioning its current relevance. Some commenters reminisce about their positive experiences with Delphi, praising its ease of use, rapid development capabilities, and stability, particularly in the 90s and early 2000s. Others express skepticism about its future, citing its perceived decline in popularity and the rise of alternative technologies. The conversation also touches on the limitations of its closed-source nature and pricing model compared to newer, open-source options, while some defend Embarcadero's stewardship and highlight Delphi's continued use in specific niche markets. There's a sense of nostalgia mixed with pragmatic assessments of Delphi's place in the modern development landscape.
The Hacker News post "Delphi Is 30" has generated a modest number of comments, mostly reflecting on personal experiences and observations about the Delphi language and its ecosystem.
Several commenters reminisce about using Delphi in the past, often for educational purposes or early career projects. One user recalls learning Delphi in high school and being impressed by its rapid application development capabilities compared to C++. Another mentions using Delphi 5 for early web development, while another still speaks fondly of Delphi's database connectivity features. These comments paint a picture of Delphi as a powerful and accessible tool, particularly in its heyday.
The decline of Delphi is also a recurring theme. Commenters discuss factors like the rise of web technologies, the perceived mismanagement by Borland and later Embarcadero, and the limitations of the VCL framework. Some express disappointment at Delphi's failure to adapt and evolve with the changing technological landscape, leading to its diminished relevance in the modern software world.
Despite this decline, a few commenters note that Delphi maintains a niche following and continues to be used in specific industries, such as industrial automation and embedded systems. One comment points out the strengths of Delphi's native code compilation and performance advantages in resource-constrained environments. Another mentions the continued use of Delphi in legacy systems, highlighting the longevity of the language and the potential for ongoing maintenance work.
A couple of commenters discuss the challenges of cross-platform development with Delphi, while others touch upon the language's syntax and features. One user expresses appreciation for Delphi's object-oriented nature, while another mentions the availability of third-party libraries.
Overall, the comments reflect a mix of nostalgia, disappointment, and pragmatic assessment of Delphi's past, present, and future. While acknowledging its decline, many commenters recognize the enduring legacy and niche relevance of the language. The conversation provides a glimpse into the experiences and perspectives of developers who have interacted with Delphi over the years.