PiLiDAR is a project demonstrating a low-cost, DIY LiDAR scanner built using a Raspberry Pi. It leverages a readily available RPLiDAR A1M8 sensor, Python code, and a simple mechanical setup involving a servo motor to rotate the LiDAR unit, creating 360-degree scans. The project provides complete instructions and software, allowing users to easily build their own LiDAR system for applications like robotics, mapping, and 3D scanning. The provided Python scripts handle data acquisition, processing, and visualization, outputting point cloud data that can be further analyzed or used with other software.
Apple's "Cubify Anything" introduces a new approach to 3D object detection within indoor scenes using monocular RGB images. It leverages a pre-trained 2D object detector to identify objects and then fits a cuboid to each detected object by estimating its 3D pose and dimensions. This method, dubbed "cubification," efficiently generates dense 3D models of indoor environments, suitable for applications like augmented reality and scene understanding. The approach simplifies the 3D detection pipeline by directly predicting cuboids instead of complex meshes or point clouds, enabling real-time performance on mobile devices. Importantly, Cubify Anything is designed to work on diverse indoor scenes without requiring specific training data for each scene.
Hacker News users discussed Apple's Cubify research, expressing excitement about its potential applications in AR/VR and robotics. Some questioned the practical use cases given the computational demands, suggesting mobile deployment would be challenging. Several commenters compared it to existing 3D modeling techniques like NeRF, noting Cubify's focus on cuboid representations might offer advantages in certain scenarios, like robot manipulation. There was also interest in the dataset used for training and the possibility of open-sourcing it. Finally, some users expressed skepticism about Apple's history of releasing research code, while others countered that their recent track record had improved.
This paper introduces a novel method for 3D scene reconstruction from images captured in adverse weather conditions like fog, rain, and snow. The approach leverages Gaussian splatting, a recent technique for representing scenes as collections of small, oriented Gaussian ellipsoids. By adapting the Gaussian splatting framework to incorporate weather effects, specifically by modeling attenuation and scattering, the method is able to reconstruct accurate 3D scenes even from degraded input images. The authors demonstrate superior performance compared to existing methods on both synthetic and real-world datasets, showing robust reconstructions in challenging visibility conditions. This improved robustness is attributed to the inherent smoothness of the Gaussian splatting representation and its ability to effectively handle noisy and incomplete data.
Hacker News users discussed the robustness of the Gaussian Splatting method for 3D scene reconstruction presented in the linked paper, particularly its effectiveness in challenging weather like fog and snow. Some commenters questioned the practical applicability due to computational cost and the potential need for specialized hardware. Others highlighted the impressive visual results and the potential for applications in autonomous driving and robotics. The reliance on LiDAR data was also discussed, with some noting its limitations in certain adverse weather conditions, potentially hindering the proposed method's overall robustness. A few commenters pointed out the novelty of the approach and its potential to improve upon existing methods that struggle with poor visibility. There was also brief mention of the challenges of accurately modelling dynamic weather phenomena in these reconstructions.
Summary of Comments ( 158 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43738561
Hacker News users discussed the PiLiDAR project with a focus on its practicality and potential applications. Several commenters questioned the effective range and resolution of the lidar given the Raspberry Pi's processing power and the motor's speed, expressing skepticism about its usefulness for anything beyond very short-range scanning. Others were more optimistic, suggesting applications like indoor mapping, robotics projects, and 3D scanning of small objects. The cost-effectiveness of the project compared to dedicated lidar units was also a point of discussion, with some suggesting that readily available and more powerful lidar units might offer better value. A few users highlighted the educational value of the project, particularly for learning about lidar technology and interfacing hardware with the Raspberry Pi.
The Hacker News post titled "Raspberry Pi Lidar Scanner" (linking to a GitHub project called PiLiDAR) has generated several comments, offering a variety of perspectives on the project.
Several users discuss the practicality and applications of such a setup. One user highlights the potential limitations due to the Raspberry Pi's processing power, suggesting that a more powerful platform might be necessary for real-time, high-resolution scanning, especially with more advanced SLAM algorithms. They also express interest in the project's potential for robotics applications. Another user suggests the possibility of using it for indoor mapping and navigation, emphasizing the affordability of the setup. A different commenter points out the previous existence of similar projects using the Raspberry Pi and lidar, indicating this isn't an entirely novel concept.
The discussion also touches upon the specific components used in the project. One comment mentions the RPLidar A1M8, a specific lidar model, and notes its limited range and resolution, suggesting alternative lidar units for improved performance depending on the desired application. This comment thread also delves into the cost-effectiveness of using the RPLidar A1 with a Raspberry Pi, considering other processing options. A separate comment chain discusses the intricacies of processing lidar data on resource-constrained devices like the Raspberry Pi, with suggestions for optimizing code and algorithms.
Some comments focus on the software aspects. One user inquires about the specific SLAM algorithm being used and its suitability for the Raspberry Pi's hardware. Another user expresses interest in the project's potential for creating 3D models of environments. There's also mention of the project's use of Python and its libraries, with some users expressing appreciation for the language choice.
A few comments touch upon the safety aspects of using lidar, particularly regarding eye safety and the power of the laser used.
In summary, the comments section explores various facets of the project, including its technical feasibility, potential applications, component choices, software implementation, and safety considerations. The discussion reveals both enthusiasm for the project's potential and a pragmatic awareness of its limitations.