Appstat is a free, open-source process monitor for Windows presented as a modern alternative to existing tools. It offers a clean and responsive UI, focusing on real-time performance monitoring with detailed metrics like CPU usage, memory consumption, I/O operations, and network activity. Appstat aims to provide a comprehensive view of system resource utilization by individual processes, enabling users to quickly identify performance bottlenecks and troubleshoot issues. It boasts features like customizable columns, sorting, filtering, process tree views, and historical data charting for deeper analysis.
Stats is a free and open-source macOS menu bar application that provides a comprehensive overview of system performance. It displays real-time information on CPU usage, memory, network activity, disk usage, battery health, and fan speeds, all within a customizable and compact menu bar interface. Users can tailor the displayed modules and their appearance to suit their needs, choosing from various graph styles and refresh rates. Stats aims to be a lightweight yet powerful alternative to larger system monitoring tools.
Hacker News users generally praised Stats' minimalist design and useful information display in the menu bar. Some suggested improvements, including customizable refresh rates, more detailed CPU information (like per-core usage), and GPU temperature monitoring for M1 Macs. Others questioned the need for another system monitor given existing options, with some pointing to iStat Menus as a more mature alternative. The developer responded to several comments, acknowledging the suggestions and clarifying current limitations and future plans. Some users appreciated the open-source nature of the project and the developer's responsiveness. There was also a minor discussion around the chosen license (GPLv3).
Summary of Comments ( 4 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43255855
HN users generally praised Appstat as a useful tool. Several pointed out its similarity to existing tools like Sysinternals Process Monitor (Procmon) while highlighting Appstat's simpler interface and easier setup as advantages. Some appreciated its focus on security-relevant events. Others suggested potential improvements, such as adding filtering capabilities, including command line arguments, and enhancing the UI with features like column sorting. A few users mentioned alternative tools they preferred, including Procmon and ETW Explorer. The developer actively responded to comments, addressing questions and acknowledging suggestions for future development.
The Hacker News post for "Show HN: Appstat – Process Monitor for Windows" generated a moderate amount of discussion, with several commenters offering their perspectives and experiences.
A significant portion of the conversation revolves around comparing Appstat to existing process monitoring tools, particularly Process Monitor (Procmon) from Sysinternals. Several users praise Procmon as a powerful and comprehensive tool, questioning whether Appstat offers enough unique features to justify its existence. One commenter points out the steep learning curve associated with Procmon, highlighting the need for simpler alternatives, particularly for less experienced users. They suggest Appstat could potentially fill this niche.
The author of Appstat actively participates in the thread, responding to queries and providing clarification about its features. They emphasize the tool's focus on providing a more user-friendly interface compared to Procmon, acknowledging that Procmon offers greater depth in terms of data collection. They also discuss Appstat's specific use cases, such as troubleshooting application crashes and identifying performance bottlenecks. This direct engagement from the creator allows for a deeper understanding of the tool's purpose and intended audience.
One commenter expresses skepticism about the cross-platform capabilities of Appstat, specifically questioning its performance on Linux. The author responds by acknowledging the current limitations of the Linux version and outlining future development plans. This exchange provides valuable insight into the current state of the project and its roadmap.
Further discussion centers on the potential licensing model for Appstat. One commenter inquires about plans for open-sourcing the project. The author responds by stating that they are currently considering various options, including a potential dual-licensing approach. This suggests the possibility of both a free community edition and a paid commercial version.
The overall sentiment within the comments section appears to be cautiously optimistic. While several users acknowledge the value of existing tools like Procmon, there's also a recognition that there's room for alternative solutions with different design philosophies and target user groups. The author's active participation and responsiveness to feedback contribute positively to the discussion, leaving a favorable impression of the project and its potential.