Jasmine is a Y Combinator-backed startup aiming to automate Renewable Energy Certificate (REC) compliance and payouts for solar projects. They handle the complex process of registering, tracking, and monetizing RECs, simplifying revenue generation for solar developers and asset owners. This automation reduces administrative overhead and ensures projects capitalize on the full value of their renewable energy generation.
Karsa, a YC W25 startup, launched a platform for buying and saving stablecoins internationally. It aims to provide an easier way for people in emerging markets to access and hold USD-pegged stablecoins as a hedge against local currency volatility and inflation. The platform allows users to purchase stablecoins directly with their local currency through various payment methods, and then earn interest on their holdings. Karsa emphasizes a simple and accessible user experience, designed specifically for individuals in these markets who may be less familiar with cryptocurrencies.
Several commenters on Hacker News expressed skepticism about the need for Karsa, questioning whether the problem it solves is significant enough, especially given existing solutions like Wise and Revolut. Some doubted the claim of cheaper and faster transfers, citing personal experience with these alternatives. Others questioned the regulatory landscape and potential legal hurdles for operating in multiple jurisdictions. A few commenters requested clarification on Karsa's specific advantages, particularly concerning fees and exchange rates, while some expressed interest in using the service for specific use cases like paying international employees. Overall, the comments reflected a cautious but curious attitude towards Karsa, with many seeking more information to assess its true value proposition.
Summary of Comments ( 1 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43705065
Hacker News users discuss Jasmine's potential, focusing on the complexity of Renewable Energy Certificate (REC) markets. Some express skepticism about automating such a nuanced process, citing variations in state regulations and the potential for fraud. Others see value in streamlining REC management, particularly for smaller solar installers. Several commenters inquire about Jasmine's pricing model and integration with existing solar software. The discussion also touches on the challenges of accurately tracking REC ownership and the importance of transparency in the market. A few users with experience in the solar industry offer insights into the specific pain points Jasmine aims to address, validating the need for such a solution.
The Hacker News post discussing Jasmine, a YC S22 startup automating REC compliance and payouts for solar, has generated a moderate number of comments, primarily focusing on the complexities of the REC market and the potential value proposition of Jasmine.
Several commenters highlight the fragmented and opaque nature of the REC market, with varying regulations and pricing across different states and jurisdictions. This complexity, they argue, creates significant overhead for solar installers and asset owners who must navigate these intricacies to monetize their RECs. Some users shared personal anecdotes about the challenges of tracking generation data, registering RECs, and finding buyers, emphasizing the pain point Jasmine aims to address.
A recurring theme in the comments is skepticism regarding the defensibility of Jasmine's business model. Commenters question whether the automation provided by Jasmine is truly novel or difficult to replicate, and whether the value proposition is strong enough to justify their fees. Some suggest that existing energy management platforms or in-house solutions might be sufficient for many solar project owners. Concerns were also raised about potential competition from larger players in the renewable energy space.
Some commenters inquire about the specifics of Jasmine's pricing model, integration with existing systems, and handling of different REC types (SRECs, RECs, etc.). Others express interest in learning more about the company's target market and go-to-market strategy.
A few commenters offered constructive feedback to the founders, suggesting potential features or areas of focus, such as incorporating carbon offset markets or providing more granular reporting and analytics. One commenter questioned the emphasis on automation, suggesting that human expertise and relationship management might still be crucial in navigating the REC market.
Overall, the comments reflect a cautious optimism towards Jasmine's potential, acknowledging the need for a streamlined REC management solution while also raising valid concerns about the company's competitive landscape and long-term viability. The discussion highlights the complexities and nuances of the REC market and the challenges faced by solar project owners in maximizing the value of their renewable energy assets.