A developer created a web-based simulator that recreates the experience of using a telegraph. The simulator allows users to input a message, which is then converted into Morse code and visually transmitted as flashing lights and audible clicks, mimicking the original technology. It also features a receiver that decodes the transmitted Morse code back into text. This project provides a hands-on way to understand and interact with the historical process of telegraphic communication.
The blog post explores a purported connection between Mike Oldfield's "Tubular Bells," famously used in The Exorcist, and Morse code. The author analyzes a specific section of the album and argues that the tubular bells play a sequence that translates to "BELLS." While acknowledging the possibility of coincidence, the author speculates that Oldfield, known for his meticulous approach to composition and interest in radio, might have intentionally embedded this message as a playful nod to his amateur radio background, potentially referencing his callsign "G3SWE." The post further links this potential Morse code to a rumored "curse" surrounding The Exorcist, suggesting the message could be interpreted as a signature or playful acknowledgement of the film's ominous themes.
HN users discuss the plausibility and technical details of the claim that Mike Oldfield embedded Morse code into "Tubular Bells." Some are skeptical, pointing out the difficulty of discerning Morse within complex music and suggesting coincidental patterns. Others analyze specific sections, referencing the provided audio examples, and debate whether the supposed Morse is intentional or simply an artifact of the instrumentation. The use of a spectrogram is highlighted as a method for clearer analysis, and discussion arises around the feasibility of Oldfield's equipment and knowledge of Morse at the time. Some express appreciation for the in-depth analysis of the blog post while others remain unconvinced, citing the lack of definitive proof. The comment thread also diverges into discussions about Oldfield's other work and general discussions on musical analysis techniques.
Summary of Comments ( 16 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43260251
Hacker News users generally praised the Telegraph simulator for its simplicity, clean design, and accurate recreation of the Telegraph experience. Several commenters appreciated the nostalgia it evoked, recalling childhood memories of playing with similar toys. Some suggested improvements, such as adding sound or the ability to send messages between two simulated devices. A few users discussed the historical significance of the Telegraph and its role in communication technology. One commenter even shared a personal anecdote about their grandfather's career as a telegraph operator. The overall sentiment was positive, with many finding the project a charming and educational homage to a bygone era of communication.
The Hacker News post "Show HN: I Built a Telegraph Simulator" at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43260251 has generated several comments discussing the project and the history/mechanics of telegraphs.
One commenter expresses admiration for the project, particularly the attention to detail in simulating the sound and feel of a telegraph. They mention the historical significance of telegraphy, highlighting its role as a precursor to the internet. This commenter also draws a parallel between learning Morse code and learning to program, suggesting that both involve mastering a new language to communicate with a machine.
Another commenter delves into the technical aspects of telegraph operation, explaining how the length of dots and dashes could vary depending on the skill and individual style of the operator, a phenomenon known as "fist." They also discuss the use of "Phillips Code," a shorthand system used by telegraph operators to speed up communication, further highlighting the nuances of the technology.
One commenter asks a clarifying question about the project, inquiring whether the user needs physical telegraph hardware to interact with the simulator. The creator of the project responds, explaining that the simulator can be used with a straight key or a mouse, offering flexibility to users.
Several commenters share anecdotes and historical information related to telegraphs. One recounts a childhood experience of encountering a working telegraph at a historical site, emphasizing the lasting impact of experiencing this technology firsthand. Another discusses the historical context of telegraph usage during wartime, mentioning its vulnerability to interception. Another still points out the role of telegraphs in the development of standardized time zones.
A few comments center on the practical applications of the project. One commenter suggests using the simulator as an educational tool to teach Morse code, highlighting its interactive and engaging nature. Another discusses the possibility of using the simulator for amateur radio communication.
Overall, the comments on the Hacker News post demonstrate significant interest in the telegraph simulator, with discussions ranging from technical details and historical context to potential applications and personal experiences. The commenters' engagement with the project reveals a fascination with the history of communication technology and an appreciation for the creator's effort in bringing this piece of history to life in a digital format.