The IEEE offers a credentialing program designed to recognize and enhance professional development in various technical fields. These credentials, including certifications and certificates, validate expertise in areas like software development, systems engineering, and cybersecurity. The program aims to help individuals advance their careers by demonstrating competency, staying current with industry trends, and gaining a competitive edge. IEEE credentials are built upon rigorous standards, peer review, and continuing education requirements, ensuring quality and relevance in a rapidly evolving technological landscape. They offer individuals a way to showcase specialized knowledge and skills to potential employers and clients.
A new "Calm Technology" certification aims to highlight digital products and services designed to be less intrusive and demanding of users' attention. Developed by Amber Case, the creator of the concept, the certification evaluates products based on criteria like peripheral awareness, respect for user attention, and providing a sense of calm. Companies can apply for certification, hoping to attract users increasingly concerned with digital overload and the negative impacts of constant notifications and distractions. The goal is to encourage a more mindful approach to technology design, promoting products that integrate seamlessly into life rather than dominating it.
HN users discuss the difficulty of defining "calm technology," questioning the practicality and subjectivity of a proposed certification. Some argue that distraction is often a function of the user's intent and self-control, not solely the technology itself. Others express skepticism about the certification process, wondering how "calmness" can be objectively measured and enforced, particularly given the potential for manipulation by manufacturers. The possibility of a "calm technology" standard being co-opted by marketing is also raised. A few commenters appreciate the concept but worry about its implementation. The overall sentiment leans toward cautious skepticism, with many believing the focus should be on individual digital wellness practices rather than relying on a potentially flawed certification system.
Summary of Comments ( 1 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42821654
Hacker News users discussing the IEEE credentialing program express skepticism and concern about its value. Several commenters question whether the program offers any real benefits, particularly given its cost. Some suggest it might be more beneficial for engineers to focus on building a strong portfolio and gaining practical experience rather than pursuing this credential. The lack of employer recognition and the seemingly generic nature of the offered credentials are recurring criticisms. A few commenters mention the potential for the program to be useful in specific niche areas or for individuals earlier in their careers, but the overall sentiment leans towards viewing it as unnecessary and potentially even harmful to the IEEE's reputation.
The Hacker News post titled "IEEE Credentialing Program" with the link to https://www.ieee.org/education/credentialing/index.html has several comments discussing the value and relevance of IEEE certifications.
Several commenters express skepticism about the value proposition of these certifications. One commenter questions whether these credentials hold any weight in the job market, particularly compared to practical experience and demonstrable skills. They suggest that potential employers are more interested in a candidate's portfolio and contributions to open-source projects. This sentiment is echoed by others who point out that actual skills and a proven track record are far more valuable than certifications, especially in the fast-paced tech industry. They argue that the time and money invested in pursuing these credentials could be better spent on acquiring practical skills and building a strong portfolio.
Another commenter points out the potential for "credential creep," where certifications become increasingly numerous and specialized, potentially leading to a situation where individuals feel pressured to acquire a multitude of credentials just to stay competitive. They express concern that this could create an unnecessary barrier to entry for newcomers and those without the resources to pursue these certifications.
One commenter mentions the potential benefit of these certifications for individuals working in specific regulated industries or for those seeking international recognition of their skills. They acknowledge that while the value might be limited in general software development, there could be niche applications where these credentials could be advantageous.
A few commenters discuss their personal experiences with professional certifications, with mixed opinions. One shares their positive experience with a different certification program, highlighting the structured learning and networking opportunities it provided. However, others remain unconvinced about the value of the IEEE certifications specifically, citing a lack of recognition within their professional circles.
One commenter questions the relevance of the IEEE in the modern tech landscape, suggesting that the organization might be trying to stay relevant by introducing these credentialing programs. They imply that the focus should be on providing valuable resources and fostering community rather than on certifications.
Overall, the comments reflect a general skepticism towards the IEEE Credentialing Program, with many commenters questioning its practical value and relevance in the current job market. While some acknowledge potential niche benefits, the dominant sentiment is that practical skills, experience, and a strong portfolio are far more valuable than certifications.