This study re-examines the use of star clocks, or diagonal star tables, in ancient Egypt. By digitally reconstructing the night sky as seen from specific locations and times in Egypt, the researchers demonstrate how these tables functioned. Each table tracked fifteen decanal stars, marking the passage of time throughout the night by their sequential risings and culminations. The study reveals a continuous tradition of star clock use spanning multiple dynasties, with tables adjusted for precession. It also highlights regional variations and potential administrative uses of these astronomical tools, solidifying their importance for timekeeping in ancient Egyptian society.
Esri has released the USA Hydro Network v1.0, the most detailed open map of US surface water ever created. Derived from the 3D Elevation Program's 1-meter resolution data, this hydro network boasts unparalleled accuracy and granularity, providing a much clearer picture of water flow compared to previous datasets. It features over 100 million flowline segments and includes detailed information on flow direction, stream order, and watershed boundaries, offering valuable insights for applications like hydrologic modeling, environmental management, and infrastructure planning. The data is freely available for download and use.
HN commenters generally expressed enthusiasm for the detailed water map, praising its visual appeal and potential uses for conservation, research, and recreation. Some raised concerns about the map's accuracy, particularly regarding ephemeral streams and the potential impact on regulatory determinations. A few commenters discussed the underlying data sources and technical aspects of the map's creation, including its resolution and the challenges of mapping dynamic water systems. Others shared links to related resources like the National Hydrography Dataset (NHD) and other mapping tools, comparing and contrasting them to the featured map. Several commenters also highlighted the importance of accurate water data for addressing various environmental challenges.
Summary of Comments ( 2 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42774228
HN users discussed the practicality and accuracy of Egyptian star clocks, questioning their true function. Some doubted their precision for timekeeping, suggesting they were more likely used for ritual or symbolic purposes related to the rising and setting of specific stars. Others highlighted the complexity of deciphering their meaning due to the long passage of time and shifting astronomical alignments. The role of priests in using these clocks, and their potential connection to religious ceremonies, was also a topic of interest. Several commenters appreciated the visual representation of the star clocks, but wished for more technical details and context within the ArcGIS story map itself. The limited written record from the Egyptians themselves makes definitive conclusions difficult, leaving room for speculation and further research.
The Hacker News post titled "An Astronomical View of Ancient Egyptian Star Clocks (2021)" has several comments discussing the linked article about Egyptian star clocks. Several users engaged with the content, expressing interest and offering further insights.
One commenter pointed out the cleverness of the Egyptian system, which didn't require explicit measurement of time intervals but instead focused on marking specific points in the night. This eliminated the need for precise, consistent timekeeping devices, which were technologically challenging at the time. They highlighted the practicality of this approach for religious observances and civil purposes.
Another user expanded on this idea, drawing a parallel between these star clocks and sundials. They noted that both rely on celestial movements to mark specific times or events rather than measuring durations. This user also touched on the cultural significance of these instruments, connecting them to the Egyptian understanding of cosmology and the passage of time.
Furthering the discussion on practicality, another comment mentioned the limitations of the star clocks due to weather conditions. The reliance on visible stars meant that cloudy nights rendered the clocks unusable. This observation prompted a short discussion about the challenges of timekeeping in ancient civilizations and the limitations imposed by the available technology.
One user expressed fascination with the diagonal star tables and the inherent astronomical knowledge they represent. They questioned the level of precision these ancient Egyptians possessed and wondered about the development and refinement of their astronomical observations over time.
A separate comment pointed out a detail from the linked article about the orientation of the star tables and their relation to the cardinal directions. This comment enriched the understanding of how these tables were used in practice, connecting the physical layout to the observation of star movements.
A final comment mentioned the inherent imprecision of the Egyptian system and the varying lengths of hours throughout the year. This contributed to the overall discussion of the limitations of these star clocks while acknowledging their ingenuity within the context of the available technology and knowledge.
In summary, the comments on Hacker News demonstrate a genuine appreciation for the ingenuity and cultural significance of the Egyptian star clocks. They also delve into the practical limitations and inherent imprecision of the system, reflecting a nuanced understanding of ancient Egyptian timekeeping practices.