Archaeologists in England unearthed a remarkably intact, 1,700-year-old Roman chicken egg during a waterlogged site excavation. While other eggs from the same site broke upon discovery, this one remained whole, likely due to its preservation in a soft, oxygen-poor environment. Although the egg did eventually crack during a later cleaning, it initially held its shape and even contained some liquid within. Researchers believe the egg was a votive offering, intentionally placed at the site as part of a ritual practice.
Divers off the coast of Spain have recovered remnants of a Phoenician shipwreck dating back approximately 2,600 years. The vessel, discovered near Mazarrón, carried ingots of tin likely originating from the Iberian Peninsula or even Cornwall, suggesting extensive trade networks during the 7th century B.C. Researchers believe the ship sank during a storm while en route to Cadiz, where the tin would have been exchanged for other valuable goods. The recovered artifacts, including the remarkably well-preserved tin ingots marked with Phoenician script, offer valuable insight into ancient maritime trade and shipbuilding practices.
Hacker News users discuss the exciting discovery of the 2,600-year-old Phoenician shipwreck. Some express amazement at the preservation of the ship after so long underwater, particularly the survival of organic materials like wood. Several commenters delve into the historical significance of the find, highlighting the Phoenicians' extensive maritime trade network and the potential for this wreck to offer new insights into their seafaring technology and trade practices. One user questions the description of the ship as "Phoenician," pointing out the complexities of assigning a distinct national identity to ancient Mediterranean peoples. Others discuss the legal and ethical aspects of recovering artifacts from shipwrecks, and the challenges of preserving them. Several share additional resources, including links to documentaries about ancient shipwrecks and information about other Phoenician archaeological finds.
Summary of Comments ( 25 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43683870
Hacker News users discussed the fragility of the egg and the unlikelihood of it surviving intact for so long. Some questioned the claim it hadn't broken, suggesting hairline fractures invisible to the naked eye were possible. Others pointed to the potential for the egg to be much younger than claimed, citing the difficulty of precise dating for organic materials. The discussion also touched on the variability of preservation conditions in different soil types, and speculated about the egg's original purpose, like being part of a burial ritual. Some users expressed disappointment that the article lacked information about the egg's contents beyond it being "liquid," and hoped future analysis would reveal more.
The Hacker News post titled "1,700 year old egg never broke" (linking to an Atlas Obscura article about a Roman-era egg found intact underwater) generated a moderate number of comments, mostly focusing on speculation about the egg's preservation and the plausibility of the story.
Several commenters questioned the egg's age and the claim it hadn't broken. One user pointed out the discrepancy between the headline's claim of 1,700 years and the article's mention of a 4th-century Roman ship, suggesting a potential error in the dating. Another commenter expressed skepticism about the egg remaining intact, given the fragility of eggshells and the pressures of being submerged for such a long period. They suggested it might be a fossilized egg or that some form of mineralization had occurred.
A few commenters delved into possible explanations for the egg's preservation. One proposed the egg might have been stored in an airtight container, perhaps a ceramic jar with a sealed lid, which could have protected it from the elements and prevented decomposition. Another speculated about the role of the anaerobic underwater environment in preventing bacterial breakdown, potentially contributing to the egg's long-term survival. A commenter with apparent archaeological knowledge suggested that the mud and sediment at the bottom of the water could have created a stable, low-oxygen environment that aided in preservation.
Some comments offered lighter takes on the situation. One user jokingly pondered the potential smell upon opening the egg, anticipating a potent aroma. Another quipped about the possibility of extracting ancient DNA and recreating Roman-era chickens.
While a few commenters expressed interest in learning more about the scientific analysis of the egg and hoped for future updates, the overall tone of the discussion was one of cautious curiosity mixed with a healthy dose of skepticism. There wasn't a single "most compelling" comment, but rather a collection of observations and hypotheses reflecting a shared interest in the unusual find.