Toyota has slashed the effective price of its Mirai hydrogen fuel cell vehicle in California. By combining a $5,050 price reduction with an additional $15,000 worth of free hydrogen fuel, the car's cost to consumers could be as low as just over $15,000, depending on the lease deal. This aggressive pricing strategy aims to increase adoption of hydrogen vehicles and address the limited refueling infrastructure currently available.
The Toyota Prius, launched in 1997, revolutionized the auto industry by popularizing hybrid technology. While not the first hybrid, its combination of fuel efficiency, practicality, and affordability brought the technology into the mainstream. This spurred other automakers to develop their own hybrid models, driving innovation and establishing hybrid powertrains as a viable alternative to traditional gasoline engines. The Prius's success also elevated Toyota's brand image, associating it with environmental consciousness and technological advancement, paving the way for broader acceptance of electrified vehicles.
Hacker News commenters generally agree that the Prius had a significant impact, but debate its nature. Some argue it normalized hybrids, paving the way for EVs, while others credit it with popularizing fuel efficiency as a desirable trait. A few contend its main contribution was demonstrating the viability of electronically controlled cars, enabling further innovation. Several commenters share personal anecdotes about Prius ownership, highlighting its reliability and practicality. Some critique its driving experience and aesthetics, while others discuss the social signaling aspect of owning one. The environmental impact is also debated, with some questioning the overall benefit of hybrids compared to other solutions. A recurring theme is Toyota's missed opportunity to capitalize on its early lead in the hybrid market and transition more aggressively to full EVs.
Summary of Comments ( 10 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42829795
Hacker News commenters express skepticism about the viability of hydrogen cars, even with the substantial price reduction and fuel incentive. Several point out the lack of hydrogen fueling infrastructure as a major hurdle, emphasizing the inconvenience compared to readily available EV charging. Others question the "free fuel" claim, suspecting it's baked into the cost and highlighting the ongoing expense after the initial allotment. Some commenters also criticize hydrogen's overall efficiency compared to battery electric vehicles, citing energy losses in production, storage, and transport. A few express interest in the technology, but the overall sentiment leans towards practicality concerns and doubts about hydrogen's future in personal transportation.
The Hacker News post discussing the Toyota Mirai's price reduction and fuel incentive generated a moderate number of comments, mostly focusing on the practicality and economics of hydrogen fuel cell vehicles.
Several commenters expressed skepticism about hydrogen as a viable fuel source for personal vehicles. One highlighted the inefficiency of the entire hydrogen production and distribution process, arguing that battery electric vehicles (BEVs) are significantly more energy-efficient. This sentiment was echoed by others who pointed out the lack of hydrogen refueling infrastructure compared to the readily available charging options for BEVs. Another commenter questioned the "free fuel" claim, suggesting that its cost is likely built into the vehicle's price or subsidized, ultimately passing the expense on to the consumer or taxpayer.
Some commenters discussed the challenges of storing and transporting hydrogen. One mentioned the energy-intensive process of compressing or liquefying hydrogen, further reducing its overall efficiency. Another pointed out the safety concerns associated with storing highly flammable hydrogen gas, comparing it to the challenges faced by natural gas vehicles.
A few commenters touched upon the potential benefits of hydrogen, particularly for larger vehicles like trucks and buses, where the weight and range limitations of batteries become more significant. However, even these commenters acknowledged the current infrastructure limitations and the need for significant investment in hydrogen production and distribution.
One commenter offered a more nuanced perspective, suggesting that hydrogen could have a role in specific niche applications, such as long-haul trucking or in regions with abundant renewable energy resources for hydrogen production. However, they agreed that for the average consumer, BEVs remain a more practical and economical option.
A couple of commenters mentioned the environmental impact of hydrogen production, noting that unless the hydrogen is produced using renewable energy sources, it offers little to no environmental advantage over gasoline-powered vehicles.
While some comments briefly mentioned the Mirai's features and performance, the overall discussion primarily revolved around the broader debate of hydrogen versus battery electric vehicles, with the majority of commenters expressing skepticism about the viability of hydrogen for personal transportation in the near future. There wasn't a significant amount of discussion specifically about the Mirai itself beyond its pricing and fuel incentive.