By day, Dan Lane works at a Co-op in Exeter. By night, he's a globally recognized logo designer known as the "Lord of the Logos," creating iconic designs for bands like The Black Dahlia Murder and Aborted. His portfolio spans over 400 logos, including album artwork and merchandise designs for clients worldwide, a passion he pursues in his free time while maintaining his unassuming day job. He's built this impressive career largely through word-of-mouth and online networking within the metal music scene.
The original poster is exploring alternative company structures, specifically cooperatives (co-ops), for a SaaS business and seeking others' experiences with this model. They're interested in understanding the practicalities, benefits, and drawbacks of running a SaaS as a co-op, particularly concerning attracting investment, distributing profits, and maintaining developer motivation. They wonder if the inherent democratic nature of co-ops might hinder rapid decision-making, a crucial aspect of the competitive SaaS landscape. Essentially, they're questioning whether the co-op model is compatible with the demands of building and scaling a successful SaaS company.
Several commenters on the Hacker News thread discuss their experiences with or thoughts on alternative company models for SaaS, particularly co-ops. Some express skepticism about the scalability of co-ops for SaaS due to the capital-intensive nature of the business and the potential difficulty in attracting and retaining top talent without competitive salaries and equity. Others share examples of successful co-ops, highlighting the benefits of shared ownership, democratic decision-making, and profit-sharing. A few commenters suggest hybrid models, combining aspects of co-ops with traditional structures to balance the need for both stability and shared benefits. Some also point out the importance of clearly defining roles and responsibilities within a co-op to avoid common pitfalls. Finally, several comments emphasize the crucial role of shared values and a strong commitment to the co-op model for long-term success.
Summary of Comments ( 60 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43594396
Hacker News commenters were generally unimpressed with the "Lord of the Logos" article. Several found the title misleading, as the designer's work, while prolific, wasn't particularly noteworthy or high-profile. Some criticized the writing style as hyperbolic and clickbaity, arguing the story wasn't deserving of such grand pronouncements. Others pointed out the irony of a Co-op employee designing logos for competing supermarkets. A few questioned the legality and ethics of designing logos for other companies while employed, especially given the potential for intellectual property conflicts. There was also a brief discussion about the prevalence of generic-looking logos.
The Hacker News post about the Exeter Co-op worker who designs logos has a modest number of comments, mostly focusing on the juxtaposition of his ordinary day job and creative outlet. Several commenters express appreciation for his artistic talent and the unique designs he creates.
One commenter highlights the "Lord of the Logos" moniker, finding it amusing and fitting. They also draw a parallel to Clark Kent/Superman, emphasizing the hidden talent beneath an unassuming exterior. This comparison resonates with other commenters, who enjoy the romantic notion of a secret identity.
Another thread discusses the logos themselves, with some commenters praising their retro aesthetic and clever use of negative space. They point out the effectiveness of simple, yet memorable designs, and how they stand out in a world of overly complex logos.
A few comments touch on the nature of creative work and the importance of having an outlet for self-expression, regardless of one's profession. They commend the designer for pursuing his passion alongside his day job.
Some commenters express curiosity about the designer's process and how he balances his two roles. They wonder if he plans to transition to logo design full-time or continue his current arrangement.
Overall, the comments reflect a positive reception to the article and a general admiration for the designer's artistic abilities and dedication to his craft. There isn't much in the way of controversy or debate, with most commenters simply sharing their appreciation for the story and the designs.