This project is a web-based recreation of Tom Dowdy's "Kaos", a screensaver from 1991. It features the same swirling, colorful lines and pulsating geometric shapes that made the original popular. Built with JavaScript and rendered on a canvas element, this modern homage aims to preserve and share the mesmerizing visual experience of Kaos with a new generation while offering a glimpse back in time for those familiar with the original.
A team of animators has painstakingly recreated the entirety of DreamWorks' "Bee Movie" frame-by-frame, using hand-drawn animation. This "remake," titled "The Free Movie," is intended as a transformative work of art, commenting on copyright, ownership, and the nature of filmmaking itself. It is available for free viewing on their website. The project, while visually similar to the original, features subtle alterations and imperfections inherent in the hand-drawn process, giving it a unique aesthetic. This distinguishes it from mere piracy and positions it as an artistic endeavor rather than a simple copy.
HN commenters were largely impressed by the dedication and absurdity of recreating The Bee Movie frame-by-frame. Some questioned the legality of the project, wondering about copyright infringement despite the transformative nature of the work. Others drew parallels to other painstaking fan projects, like the shot-for-shot remake of Raiders of the Lost Ark. Several commenters expressed fascination with the motivations behind such an undertaking, speculating on artistic expression, commentary on copyright, or simply the joy of a bizarre, challenging project. A few users shared their anticipation for the finished product and discussed the optimal viewing experience, suggesting a side-by-side comparison with the original.
Summary of Comments ( 16 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42963346
HN commenters largely expressed nostalgia for the original Kaos screensaver and praised the recreation's faithfulness to it. Some shared memories of using it in the 90s, while others discussed technical aspects like the original's algorithm and the challenges of recreating it using web technologies. A few pointed out minor differences between the homage and the original, like the color palette and the behavior of the "fly" element. Several commenters appreciated the simplicity and hypnotic nature of the screensaver, contrasting it with modern, more resource-intensive alternatives. There was also some discussion about the legal implications of recreating copyrighted software, and whether screen savers are still relevant today.
The Hacker News post discussing a recreation of Tom Dowdy's "Kaos" screensaver has generated a moderate number of comments, mostly focusing on nostalgia, technical details, and comparisons to the original screensaver.
Several commenters express fond memories of the original Kaos screensaver, recalling its mesmerizing visuals and the era of computing in which it existed. One user reminisces about running it on an Amiga 1200, highlighting the nostalgia factor associated with older computer graphics. Others simply express appreciation for the homage and the effort put into recreating it.
Some comments delve into the technical aspects of the recreation and the original. Discussion arises around the use of WebGL and shaders in the new version, contrasting it with the methods used to create the original screensaver. One commenter points out the differences in the color palettes and visual effects, noting that the new version seems to have brighter, more vibrant colors and smoother transitions. Another comment mentions the original screensaver's use of pre-calculated look-up tables for sine and cosine calculations, a technique employed due to the limited processing power of computers at the time. The differences in hardware capabilities between then and now are highlighted.
A few comments focus on comparing the recreation to the original Kaos. While some appreciate the recreation's modern take, others express a preference for the original's aesthetic, noting subtle differences in the movement and visual effects. One user points out that the recreation, while visually impressive, doesn't quite capture the same "feel" as the original. The specific differences are not explicitly stated, but the sentiment suggests that the nostalgic element is a key factor.
Finally, some comments explore other related screensavers and graphical demos from that era, showcasing a broader interest in the history of computer graphics and the art of demoscene. One commenter mentions Electric Sheep, another popular screensaver known for its abstract and evolving visuals.
In summary, the comments primarily reflect a mixture of nostalgia for the original Kaos screensaver, appreciation for the technical effort involved in the recreation, and discussions comparing the two versions. The thread also touches on related historical graphical demos and the advancements in computer graphics since the early 1990s.