hackslash dot org

The Dark Side of the Moomins

Posted: 2025-04-13 13:15:57

The New Statesman article explores the darker, more melancholic undercurrents present in Tove Jansson's Moomin stories, contrasting them with the often perceived simplistic, idyllic image. It highlights themes of existential dread, loneliness, and the acceptance of change and impermanence, particularly focusing on Jansson's own life experiences and struggles reflected in her work. The piece argues that this complexity adds depth and resonance to the Moominvalley world, making it appealing to both children and adults grappling with life's challenges. It ultimately positions the Moomins not as escapist fantasy, but as a nuanced exploration of the human condition.

Within the seemingly idyllic valley inhabited by the Moomins, Finnish author Tove Jansson crafted a world that, while brimming with whimsical charm and gentle adventures, also possessed a profound and often unsettling undercurrent of darkness. This duality, explored in detail by the New Statesman article "The Dark Side of the Moomins," reveals a depth and complexity that transcends the typical categorization of children's literature. Jansson's stories, though superficially lighthearted, delve into existential themes, anxieties, and the inherent precarity of existence, all masked beneath a veneer of playful fantasy.

The article elucidates how Jansson, influenced by her own experiences with war, depression, and complex family dynamics, imbued her Moomin narratives with a subtle melancholic tone. This manifests in various ways: the ever-present threat of natural disasters like floods and comets, the Groke, a chilling embodiment of loneliness and existential dread, and the characters' own internal struggles with fear, insecurity, and the search for meaning in a world that often feels indifferent to their existence. Even the seemingly utopian Moominvalley, a place of comfort and acceptance, is not immune to the intrusions of the unknown and the unsettling forces that lie just beyond its borders.

Furthermore, the article posits that Jansson utilized the Moomins as a vehicle for exploring complex psychological and philosophical concepts, tackling issues of identity, societal conformity, and the inherent contradictions within human nature. The characters, though anthropomorphic, grapple with very real and relatable dilemmas: Moomintroll's adolescent anxieties, Snufkin's restless wanderlust, and the Hemulen's obsessive need for order and categorization all serve as reflections of the human condition. This juxtaposition of childlike wonder and profound introspection is what gives the Moomin stories their enduring appeal and allows them to resonate with readers of all ages.

In essence, the article argues that the "dark side" of the Moomins is not a separate entity but rather an integral part of their charm. It is the shadows that give depth to the light, the melancholy that enhances the joy, and the exploration of difficult themes that elevates the stories beyond mere escapism. Jansson's Moominvalley, therefore, is not a saccharine paradise but a complex and nuanced microcosm of the world, reflecting both its beauty and its inherent darkness. It is a testament to Jansson's skill as a storyteller that she could weave such profound themes into seemingly simple narratives, creating a world that is both enchanting and deeply thought-provoking.

Summary of Comments ( 13 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43672593

HN users discuss the inherent darkness present in Tove Jansson's Moomin stories, agreeing with the article's premise. Several commenters share personal anecdotes about how the books resonated with them during difficult times, highlighting the Groke as a particularly potent symbol of loneliness and depression. Some point out that the seemingly idyllic Moominvalley frequently faces existential threats, mirroring the anxieties of post-war Finland. Others mention Jansson's own life experiences and struggles as reflected in the stories. The discussion also touches on the different interpretations possible depending on the reader's age and life stage, with the Moomins offering comfort and relatable themes for both children and adults.

The Hacker News post titled "The Dark Side of the Moomins" (linking to a New Statesman article about Tove Jansson and her Moomin series) has generated a moderate number of comments, many of which offer personal reflections on the Moomins and Jansson's work.

Several commenters discuss their experiences with the Moomin books and animations, highlighting the perceived darkness or melancholy that underlies the seemingly whimsical surface. Some users suggest this duality is part of the series' enduring appeal, allowing it to resonate with both children and adults on different levels. One commenter mentions how the books explore complex themes like existentialism and the acceptance of life's difficulties, contrasting this with the more sanitized versions often presented in animated adaptations.

Another thread of discussion focuses on Tove Jansson herself and the biographical context of her work. Commenters point out the influence of World War II and Finland's precarious geopolitical position on Jansson's writing, suggesting these external pressures shaped the underlying anxieties and themes present in the Moomin stories. One user notes the potential connection between Jansson's personal struggles, including her complex family relationships and societal attitudes towards her sexuality, and the themes of otherness and finding one's place explored within the Moomin world.

Some comments also touch on the different interpretations and adaptations of the Moomins across various media, acknowledging that some versions may downplay or omit certain aspects of the original books' complexity. This leads to a discussion about the challenges of adapting nuanced literary works for a broader audience, particularly when targeting children.

A few commenters recommend specific Moomin books or stories that they feel exemplify the darker or more melancholic aspects of the series, such as "Comet in Moominland" and "Moominpappa at Sea." These recommendations serve as a starting point for other users interested in exploring the deeper themes present within the Moomin universe.

Overall, the comments reflect an appreciation for the depth and complexity of Tove Jansson's work, acknowledging the coexistence of lighthearted whimsy and underlying darkness within the Moomin stories. The discussion offers personal perspectives on the series' enduring appeal and the influence of Jansson's life and times on her writing.

Ogres Are Cool

permalink

Posted: 2025-03-15 03:28:39

Colin Burrow's "Ogres Are Cool" argues that ogres, far from being simply monstrous, embody complex and often contradictory cultural anxieties. From their ambiguous origins in folklore to their modern depictions in children's stories and film, ogres reflect evolving societal fears about the other – encompassing foreignness, wildness, and the blurring of human/animal boundaries. The ogre's cannibalism, a defining characteristic, taps into primal fears of consumption and the violation of social taboos, while simultaneously offering a perverse fascination with transgression. Ultimately, the enduring appeal of the ogre lies in its capacity to embody these anxieties in a figure that is both terrifying and strangely compelling.

Colin Burrow's essay, "Ogres Are Cool," published in the London Review of Books, embarks upon a comprehensive exploration of the ogre's enduring presence within the tapestry of folklore and literature. He meticulously dissects the etymology of the word "ogre," tracing its origins back to the figure of Orcus, the Roman god of the underworld, and ultimately connecting it to the Hungarian "ogur," referencing a Turkic people historically associated with barbarism. Burrow posits that this etymological lineage imbues the ogre with a primal, almost elemental, association with fear and the unknown, effectively positioning the ogre as a symbolic representation of the external threats perceived by settled communities.

The essay further elucidates how the ogre archetype has metamorphosed throughout literary history. Burrow meticulously examines the ogre's depiction in various literary contexts, commencing with the medieval chansons de geste and continuing through the fairy tales of Perrault and the Grimm brothers. He notes the consistent portrayal of ogres as monstrous figures, often characterized by their immense size, grotesque appearance, and insatiable appetite, frequently, and most disturbingly, for human flesh. This cannibalistic tendency, Burrow argues, further cements the ogre's position as a figure of abject terror, embodying the primal fear of being consumed, both literally and metaphorically, by forces beyond human control.

However, Burrow's analysis transcends a simple cataloging of ogreish traits. He delves into the complex and often contradictory roles ogres play within these narratives. While acknowledging the ogre's predominantly negative portrayal, he also observes a certain degree of ambiguity, a potential for complexity within the monstrous facade. He highlights instances where ogres exhibit unexpected moments of vulnerability, even tenderness, suggesting a potential for redemption, or at least, a recognition of their inherent humanity, however deeply buried beneath layers of barbarity.

Burrow's examination extends to contemporary manifestations of the ogre in popular culture, referencing examples such as Shrek to illustrate how the figure has been reinterpreted and, in some cases, rehabilitated. He argues that the enduring fascination with ogres stems from their capacity to embody our deepest anxieties about the unknown, about the "other," while simultaneously offering a canvas onto which we can project our own complex and often contradictory desires and fears. In conclusion, Burrow's essay offers not merely a history of the ogre, but a profound meditation on the enduring power of monsters in the human imagination, demonstrating their capacity to evolve and adapt across cultures and time periods, reflecting our ever-shifting relationship with the world and the shadows that lurk within it.

Summary of Comments ( 9 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43369739

HN users largely agree with the author's premise that ogres are experiencing a cultural resurgence, moving away from purely monstrous depictions. Several commenters highlight Shrek as the pivotal turning point, making ogres sympathetic and even heroic. Some discuss the etymology of "ogre," linking it to Hungarian and historical figures like Attila the Hun. Others explore the shifting portrayals of ogres in various media, from Tolkien to Dungeons & Dragons, noting their complex and sometimes contradictory nature (brutal yet family-oriented). A few users push back, arguing that ogres have always had a multifaceted presence in folklore, predating Shrek. There's also a brief discussion of other "monster" rehabilitations in popular culture.

The Hacker News post "Ogres Are Cool" (linking to a London Review of Books article of the same name) generated a modest discussion with 15 comments. Several commenters engage with the premise of the article, which, based on the comments, seems to explore the evolving portrayal and cultural significance of ogres.

One commenter appreciates the author's exploration of how ogres, initially figures of terror, have become somewhat sympathetic figures. They highlight the shift from ogres being purely monstrous to their portrayal in works like "Shrek" where they possess relatable qualities and struggles. Another commenter picks up on this thread, mentioning George MacDonald's "The Princess and the Goblin" and suggesting that perhaps ogres have always held a more nuanced position in folklore than solely being objects of fear.

The discussion also touches upon the nature of folklore and mythology. One commenter remarks on the fluid nature of such stories, highlighting how they adapt and change across cultures and over time. This malleability, they suggest, is what allows figures like ogres to be reinterpreted and recontextualized.

A couple of comments offer further reading suggestions related to folklore and mythology, pointing to other analyses of fairy tales and monstrous figures. One commenter even draws a parallel to Tolkien's orcs, suggesting that they, too, underwent a similar shift from purely evil beings to more complex characters with their own motivations, particularly in the works of Tolkien's son, Christopher.

There's a brief tangent about video game representations of ogres, with one commenter mentioning how they're often portrayed as brutes or cannon fodder. Another commenter contrasts this with the nuanced portrayal of ogres in the tabletop role-playing game Dungeons & Dragons, suggesting that their depiction there allows for more complex interactions and character development.

Overall, the comments section reflects a general agreement with the article's premise and explores the evolving cultural understanding of ogres. The commenters delve into the adaptable nature of folklore, comparing different portrayals of ogres in literature and gaming, and reflecting on the shift from pure monster to more complex and sometimes sympathetic figure. The discussion remains relatively focused on the topic, without significant digressions or disagreements.

Roald Dahl on the death of his daughter (2015)

permalink

Posted: 2025-03-05 13:29:45

In 1962, Roald Dahl's daughter Olivia died from measles encephalitis at age seven. Devastated, Dahl initially retreated into grief and questioned his faith. With the encouragement of a family friend, he eventually found solace by immersing himself in the creation of a measles vaccination campaign, advocating for its importance and helping fund research. While never fully recovering from the loss, Dahl channeled his grief into a positive action, hoping to prevent other families from experiencing similar tragedy.

In a profoundly poignant and deeply personal letter penned in 1962, renowned children's author Roald Dahl grapples with the unfathomable grief of losing his seven-year-old daughter, Olivia, to measles encephalitis. The Telegraph article, published in 2015, presents this letter as a window into Dahl's "darkest hour," revealing the raw vulnerability of a man known for his whimsical and often darkly humorous stories. Dahl's words articulate the devastating swiftness of Olivia's decline, transitioning from a seemingly ordinary case of measles to a critical condition within a matter of days. He describes the initial diagnosis, the fleeting hope offered by a seemingly positive response to treatment, and the subsequent, brutal resurgence of the illness that ultimately claimed his daughter's life. The letter is saturated with a palpable sense of helplessness and disbelief, reflecting a father's desperate struggle to comprehend the senseless loss of a child so full of life. Dahl poignantly details the agonizing vigil he kept by Olivia's bedside, meticulously charting her fluctuating temperature and clinging to every flicker of hope. He expresses his utter bewilderment at the capricious nature of the disease, questioning how such a seemingly commonplace illness could inflict such devastating consequences. The letter also touches upon the profound impact Olivia's death had on Dahl's faith, expressing his disillusionment with traditional religious explanations for suffering. In its entirety, the letter serves as a heartbreaking testament to the enduring power of parental love and the profound devastation wrought by the loss of a child, offering a glimpse into the private anguish that undoubtedly shaped Dahl's subsequent life and work. The article emphasizes the contrast between the fantastical worlds Dahl created for children and the stark reality of his personal tragedy, highlighting the profound emotional depth hidden beneath the surface of his often whimsical prose.

Summary of Comments ( 43 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43266129

Hacker News users discuss Roald Dahl's reaction to the death of his daughter Olivia, with many focusing on his stoicism and attempt to find reason amidst grief. Some commenters find his eventual embrace of pseudoscience, specifically faith healing, understandable given the tragedy, while others criticize it as a dangerous path. The piece's portrayal of Dahl's complex grief resonated with several readers who shared personal experiences of loss and the different ways people cope. A few commenters also note Dahl's difficult personality, both before and after Olivia's death, questioning the simplicity of portraying him solely as a grieving father. Several users mention the irony of his later anti-vaccine stance, given that measles took his daughter's life, sparking discussion on the complexities of grief and its impact on decision-making.

The Hacker News post titled "Roald Dahl on the death of his daughter (2015)" linking to a Telegraph article about Roald Dahl's experience with the death of his daughter, Olivia, has generated a significant number of comments. Many commenters share their own experiences with childhood illness and loss, expressing empathy for Dahl and his family.

Several comments focus on the devastating impact of measles encephalitis, the illness that claimed Olivia's life. Some commenters discuss the importance of vaccination, reflecting on a time before the widespread availability of the measles vaccine and the tragic consequences of the disease. One commenter points out the historical context, noting that even with the best medical care available at the time, the outcome was often grim. Another commenter sadly recounts a similar experience with a family member lost to measles encephalitis.

There is a discussion on the apparent contradiction between Dahl's advocacy for vaccination after Olivia's death and his earlier skepticism towards medicine. Commenters explore this shift, attributing it to the profound personal impact of his daughter's death. One commenter suggests that experiencing such a loss can drastically alter one's perspective on medical intervention.

Some comments also touch upon the writing process and Dahl's ability to channel his grief into his work. One commenter speculates about whether the loss of his daughter influenced the darker themes present in some of his later stories.

A few comments delve into the medical details of measles encephalitis, sharing information about the neurological complications and the long-term effects on survivors. The discussion also highlights the swiftness with which the disease can progress.

Several commenters express admiration for Dahl's openness about his grief and his subsequent advocacy for vaccination. They praise his willingness to share such a personal and painful experience in hopes of preventing similar tragedies. The raw emotion evident in Dahl's letter resonates with many commenters, who express sympathy and understanding for his loss.

Overall, the comments section is a mix of personal anecdotes, reflections on grief and loss, and discussions about the historical context of measles and its devastating consequences. Many commenters found Dahl's story deeply moving and used the opportunity to share their own experiences and perspectives on childhood illness, vaccination, and the lasting impact of grief.

Celebrating the Timeless Allure of Tintin's Aesthetics

permalink

Posted: 2025-01-09 23:47:50

Hergé's Tintin comics maintain a timeless appeal due to their distinctive clear line style, vibrant yet realistic color palettes, and meticulous attention to detail in backgrounds and objects. This aesthetic, known as ligne claire, contributes to the stories' readability and immersive quality, allowing readers to focus on the narrative and characters. The article argues that this consistent visual style, coupled with exciting plots and engaging characters, transcends generational divides and continues to captivate audiences worldwide, solidifying Tintin's status as a classic.

This blog post, "Celebrating the Timeless Allure of Tintin's Aesthetics," embarks upon a detailed exploration of the distinctive visual appeal and enduring charm of Hergé's renowned comic book series, "The Adventures of Tintin." The author meticulously dissects the specific elements that contribute to the unique aesthetic experience of the series, emphasizing the clarity and precision of Hergé's ligne claire style. This style, characterized by strong, unwavering outlines and flat, vibrant colors, is meticulously examined as a foundational component of Tintin's enduring appeal, creating a sense of timeless elegance and immediacy that transcends generations.

The post further elaborates on Hergé's meticulous attention to detail in depicting a wide array of settings, from bustling urban landscapes to exotic, far-flung locales. This geographical diversity, rendered with meticulous research and an eye for architectural accuracy, imbues each adventure with a distinctive visual flavor, transporting the reader to a visually rich and believable world, despite the fantastical nature of certain narratives. The author underscores how these detailed environments not only serve as backdrops but also actively contribute to the storytelling, enriching the narrative and immersing the reader in Tintin's world.

Beyond the settings, the author analyzes the character design itself, highlighting the expressive simplicity of Hergé's figures. While visually straightforward, these characters, including Tintin, Snowy, Captain Haddock, and Professor Calculus, are instantly recognizable and imbued with distinct personalities conveyed through subtle yet effective visual cues. The post emphasizes the effectiveness of this minimalist approach, arguing that it enhances the characters' memorability and allows readers to readily connect with them on an emotional level.

Furthermore, the author discusses the innovative panel layouts and pacing employed by Hergé, demonstrating how these elements contribute to the dynamic and engaging nature of the storytelling. The use of varying panel sizes and perspectives is explored as a crucial tool for creating dramatic tension, controlling the flow of information, and guiding the reader's eye through the narrative. The post suggests that Hergé's masterful command of these visual techniques elevates the comic book medium to an art form, pushing beyond simple sequential storytelling and achieving a sophisticated visual language.

Finally, the post concludes by reflecting on the enduring legacy of Tintin's aesthetics, asserting that its influence can be seen in various forms of media, from animation and film to graphic design and illustration. The author posits that the timelessness of Tintin's visual style stems from its fundamental clarity, its meticulous attention to detail, and its ability to evoke a sense of wonder and adventure that resonates with audiences of all ages, cementing its place as a cornerstone of comic book art and a testament to the enduring power of visual storytelling.

Summary of Comments ( 68 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42651043

Hacker News users discuss the enduring appeal of Tintin's clear-line art style, praising its readability and ability to convey complex emotions and action. Some highlight the influence of Hergé's meticulous research and world-building on the immersive quality of the stories. Several commenters express nostalgia for their childhood experiences with Tintin, while others analyze the artistic techniques that contribute to the distinct "ligne claire" style. The lack of explicit graphic violence is also mentioned as a positive aspect, making the adventures accessible to younger readers while retaining their excitement. A few users note the problematic colonialist undertones present in some of the older albums, prompting a brief discussion about their historical context and evolving interpretations.

The Hacker News post "Celebrating the Timeless Allure of Tintin's Aesthetics" has generated several comments discussing various aspects of Hergé's artistic style and storytelling.

One commenter expresses their appreciation for the clarity and readability of Tintin comics, highlighting how the distinct linework allows for easy comprehension even in busy scenes. They contrast this with some modern comics that employ "scratchy, muddy lines" which make it difficult to discern what is happening.

Another comment focuses on the unique "ligne claire" style, noting its influence on other artists and mediums, especially animation. They mention how this clear line style, combined with Hergé's meticulous research and attention to detail, creates a sense of realism despite the cartoonish nature of the characters. This commenter also touches upon the timeless quality of Tintin, suggesting it transcends generations due to its artistic merit and engaging narratives.

The discussion also delves into the controversy surrounding certain Tintin adventures and Hergé's portrayal of different cultures. One commenter acknowledges the problematic aspects of some books, particularly "Tintin in the Congo", while still appreciating the artistic achievements of the series as a whole. They suggest viewing the work within its historical context while remaining critical of its shortcomings.

Another commenter praises the visual storytelling of the series, specifically mentioning the effective use of sound effects and onomatopoeia. They describe how these elements enhance the reading experience and contribute to the overall immersive quality of the comics.

Several commenters share their personal experiences with Tintin, reminiscing about their childhood enjoyment of the series and how it sparked their interest in different cultures and travel. These anecdotal comments demonstrate the lasting impact of Tintin on readers.

Finally, a few comments mention the influence of Tintin on other artists and designers, particularly in Europe. They note how Hergé's style has become iconic and recognizable, continuing to inspire creative work today.

Overall, the comments reflect a general appreciation for Tintin's artistic and narrative qualities, while also acknowledging some of the controversies associated with the series. The discussion highlights the enduring appeal of the clear line style, the engaging stories, and the meticulous attention to detail that characterize Hergé's work.

Stories with Tag Children's Literature

The Dark Side of the Moomins

Summary of Comments ( 13 ) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43672593

Ogres Are Cool

Summary of Comments ( 9 ) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43369739

Roald Dahl on the death of his daughter (2015)

Summary of Comments ( 43 ) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43266129

Celebrating the Timeless Allure of Tintin's Aesthetics

Summary of Comments ( 68 ) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42651043

Summary of Comments ( 13 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43672593

Summary of Comments ( 9 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43369739

Summary of Comments ( 43 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43266129

Summary of Comments ( 68 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42651043