Trevor Traynor's photo series "Newsstands, 2012-2019" documents the disappearing presence of New York City newsstands over seven years. The photos capture the diverse and often cluttered character of these small businesses, showcasing their role as a microcosm of city life. The project subtly highlights the changing urban landscape and the decline of print media as many of the featured stands eventually vanish, leaving behind empty sidewalks. The series serves as a visual elegy for a fading piece of New York's cultural fabric.
Subway Stories is a crowdsourced collection of short, true anecdotes about everyday life on the New York City subway. These vignettes capture the diverse range of human experiences that unfold underground, from chance encounters and acts of kindness to moments of absurdity and quiet observation. The website serves as a digital tapestry of the city's vibrant and often unpredictable subterranean world, offering a glimpse into the lives of the millions who pass through its tunnels each day. It's a testament to the shared humanity and unique character of the NYC subway, presenting a mosaic of moments that are both relatable and distinctly New York.
Hacker News users discuss the "Subway Stories" project, largely praising its nostalgic and artistic value. Some commenters share personal anecdotes of their own subway experiences, echoing the themes of chance encounters and shared humanity found on the site. Others analyze the technical aspects of the project, appreciating its minimalist design and questioning the choice of technology used. A few express skepticism about the authenticity of some submissions, while others lament the decline of similar community art projects in the internet age. The overall sentiment is positive, with many users finding the site to be a refreshing reminder of the unique human tapestry of the New York City subway system.
Summary of Comments ( 0 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42858029
Hacker News users generally praised the photography and nostalgic feel of the "Newsstands" project. Several commenters shared personal anecdotes about their experiences with newsstands, highlighting their role as community hubs and lamenting their decline. Some discussed the changing media landscape and the impact of digital news on print publications, which contributed to the disappearance of these businesses. A few users pointed out technical aspects of the photographs, like the consistent framing and lighting, while others appreciated the project's focus on a specific, vanishing piece of urban life. A couple of New Yorkers offered insights into the continued existence (albeit diminished) of newsstands in the city, noting their evolution towards selling snacks and beverages.
The Hacker News post titled "Newsstands, 2012-2019" (linking to an article showcasing photos of newsstands) sparked a diverse and engaging discussion in the comments section.
Several users reminisced about the role of newsstands in their lives and the changing media landscape. One commenter recounted their experience working at a newsstand in the 1980s, highlighting the social aspect and the variety of publications available. This sparked further discussion about the community aspect of newsstands, with another user lamenting the loss of these local hubs of information and connection.
The decline of print media and the rise of digital alternatives were recurring themes. Commenters discussed the impact of the internet and smartphones on news consumption habits. One user pointed out the irony of viewing photographs of physical newsstands on a digital platform. Another suggested that the nostalgia surrounding newsstands might stem from a simpler time before the constant influx of information from the internet.
Several comments focused on the aesthetic appeal of the photographs, praising the photographer's composition and the nostalgic atmosphere captured in the images. One user specifically complimented the photographer's ability to capture the "texture" of the city.
Some commenters also touched upon the practical challenges faced by newsstand owners, such as increasing rent and declining sales. One comment pointed out the shift in inventory from primarily newspapers and magazines to snacks and drinks as a means of survival.
A couple of commenters shared personal anecdotes related to newsstands, adding a human touch to the discussion. One user shared a story about their grandfather owning a newsstand.
Overall, the comments section reflected a blend of nostalgia, appreciation for the photography, and recognition of the societal changes that have led to the decline of newsstands. The discussion remained grounded in the subject matter and offered diverse perspectives without veering into unrelated topics.