The MCP Servers Directory (mcpso) is a community-driven project cataloging Minecraft protocol servers and proxies. It aims to provide a comprehensive, easily searchable resource for users, developers, and researchers interested in various server implementations, including those supporting older Minecraft versions or offering modified gameplay. The directory includes key information such as supported Minecraft versions, software license, project status (active/inactive), and links to relevant resources like source code repositories, websites, and documentation. Its goal is to facilitate discovery and exploration of the diverse Minecraft server ecosystem.
This GitHub repository, titled "Directory of MCP Servers," aims to establish and maintain a comprehensive, publicly accessible list of Minecraft servers that utilize the Modified Client Protocol (MCP). MCP is a modification framework that allows for extensive client-side customizations and enhancements to the Minecraft experience. The directory itself is structured as a JSON file hosted on the repository, enabling easy parsing and integration by third-party tools and applications. The JSON structure categorizes servers based on various criteria, including the specific MCP version they support, the server's intended gameplay focus (such as anarchy, survival, or creative), and any unique features or modifications they offer. Each server entry includes essential details like the server's IP address and port, allowing players to directly connect. The repository also outlines guidelines for server owners who wish to have their MCP-enabled servers added to the directory, emphasizing the importance of accurate and up-to-date information. This initiative seeks to streamline the process of discovering and joining MCP servers, fostering a more connected and accessible community for players interested in exploring the extended possibilities offered by this modification framework. The project encourages community contributions and maintains an open-source approach to ensure the directory remains a valuable and evolving resource for the MCP Minecraft community. The stated goal is to provide a central, reliable, and easily navigable hub for anyone seeking MCP servers, regardless of their specific interests within the modified Minecraft landscape.
Summary of Comments ( 35 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44016336
Several commenters on Hacker News expressed interest in the potential of Minecraft server discovery using the MCP protocol, highlighting its advantages over DNS-based server lists. Some users discussed the technical challenges of implementing such a system, including scaling and potential abuse. Others shared nostalgia for older, simpler server discovery methods, like the in-game server browser or community-maintained lists. A few questioned the necessity of a new system given existing solutions. One commenter provided a link to a related project, further demonstrating interest in decentralized server browsing.
The Hacker News post titled "Directory of MCP Servers" (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44016336) has a modest number of comments, sparking a brief discussion around the utility and nature of the project.
One commenter expresses appreciation for the directory, highlighting its usefulness for players seeking servers compatible with older Minecraft versions. They specifically mention the challenge of finding servers for these older versions and praise the directory for filling this gap.
Another commenter inquires about the operational aspects of the directory, specifically asking how servers are added. This leads to a reply from what appears to be the project maintainer, who explains that server owners add their own servers through a pull request to the GitHub repository where the directory is hosted. This clarifies the community-driven nature of the project and its reliance on server owners to maintain up-to-date information.
A further comment delves into the technical details of the project, noting the use of GitHub Pages for hosting the directory. The commenter questions the practicality of this approach for a larger project due to the lack of server-side logic with GitHub Pages. They suggest alternative hosting solutions, like Netlify or Vercel, which might be better equipped to handle dynamic updates or more complex features in the future if the directory expands significantly. This comment offers a forward-thinking perspective on the project's potential scalability challenges.
Finally, another comment circles back to the core purpose of the directory, emphasizing the importance of preserving older versions of Minecraft. This commenter expresses a sentiment of nostalgia for these older versions and underscores the value of the directory in allowing players to continue enjoying these historical versions of the game.
In summary, the comments are primarily focused on the practical aspects of the directory: its utility for finding older Minecraft servers, the mechanics of adding servers, the hosting solution used, and the broader context of preserving older versions of the game. While not a lengthy or deeply analytical discussion, the comments offer valuable insights into the project's purpose, functionality, and potential future directions.