Ed Smylie, a NASA engineer crucial to the Apollo 13 rescue, died at 95. He designed the makeshift carbon dioxide scrubber that saved the astronauts from asphyxiation after an oxygen tank exploded, famously using duct tape and other readily available materials based on instructions radioed from Mission Control. His quick thinking and ingenuity under immense pressure were essential to the mission's survival and became a legendary example of improvisation in the face of a life-or-death crisis.
Japanese startup ispace's HAKUTO-R Mission 1 lunar lander has successfully entered lunar orbit, marking a significant milestone for the first private mission to attempt a Moon landing. The lander is scheduled to attempt a soft landing in June within the Atlas crater, aiming to deploy payloads including a two-wheeled rover developed by the Japanese space agency JAXA, a rover from the United Arab Emirates, and a transformable lunar robot. The successful orbital insertion puts ispace on track to become the first private company to achieve this feat.
Hacker News commenters generally expressed excitement and cautious optimism about ispace's Hakuto-R mission. Several pointed out the significance of a private company achieving lunar orbit, viewing it as a positive step for space exploration and commercialization. Some discussed the technical challenges of the landing, particularly the complexities of terrain navigation and communication delays. A few commenters raised concerns about the lack of live coverage of the landing attempt, while others speculated on the potential scientific and economic benefits of future lunar missions, including resource extraction. There was also discussion about the broader context of the "new space race" and the growing involvement of private companies in space exploration.
Summary of Comments ( 15 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44005668
HN commenters express admiration for Ed Smylie's ingenuity and quick thinking in devising the carbon dioxide scrubber adapter that saved the Apollo 13 astronauts. Several highlight the contrast between this crucial, life-saving hack and the advanced technology surrounding the mission, emphasizing the importance of practical skills and improvisation. Some commenters share anecdotes about meeting Smylie or hearing him speak, describing him as humble and down-to-earth. Others discuss the broader significance of the Apollo 13 mission and the collaborative effort that brought the crew home safely. A few users also correct minor details in the original article or provide additional context about the mission and the lunar module's life support systems.
The Hacker News post about Ed Smylie, who helped save the Apollo 13 crew, generated several comments reflecting on his ingenuity and the significance of his contribution. Many commenters expressed admiration for Smylie's quick thinking and problem-solving skills under immense pressure. The "mailbox" solution he devised, using duct tape and other readily available materials to create a makeshift carbon dioxide scrubber, was highlighted as a testament to his practical engineering prowess.
Several commenters emphasized the importance of this seemingly simple fix, pointing out that it was crucial for the survival of the Apollo 13 astronauts. They praised Smylie and his team's ability to improvise a solution using limited resources and within a tight timeframe. Some comments also touched upon the broader significance of the Apollo 13 mission and the collective effort required to overcome the life-threatening challenges it presented.
A few comments provided additional context or anecdotes related to the Apollo 13 mission and the ingenuity of the engineers involved. One commenter mentioned the contrast between the sophisticated technology of the spacecraft and the relatively low-tech solution that ultimately saved the crew, highlighting the importance of practical skills and adaptability even in the age of advanced technology. Another commenter discussed the human element of the Apollo 13 story, emphasizing the courage and resourcefulness of everyone involved.
Overall, the comments on the Hacker News post reflect a deep appreciation for Ed Smylie's contribution to the Apollo 13 rescue and a broader admiration for the ingenuity and problem-solving skills displayed by the engineers and astronauts involved in the mission.