The New-York Historical Society's 2015 blog post highlights its collection of Civil War stereographs, offering a glimpse into the 19th-century phenomenon of 3D viewing. These double photographs, viewed through a stereoscope, provided immersive experiences for audiences eager to connect with the war's realities. The post showcases examples depicting battlefields, encampments, and portraits of soldiers, emphasizing the power of this technology to transport viewers back in time and offer a visceral understanding of the conflict. The collection reveals not only the war's devastating impact but also the evolving role of photography in documenting and disseminating information.
Jane Lane, a Royalist's daughter, played a crucial role in Charles II's escape to France after his defeat at the Battle of Worcester in 1651. Disguised as her servant and provided with a pass to travel to Bristol ostensibly to visit a pregnant friend, Charles was able to evade Parliamentarian forces. Lane's calm demeanor and quick thinking during several close calls, along with the assistance of other Royalist sympathizers, allowed Charles to eventually reach Shoreham and escape to France. This daring and successful feat cemented Lane's place in history as a key figure in the Restoration.
Hacker News users discuss the historical accuracy and plausibility of the article's premise. Several express skepticism that a single maid could have played such a pivotal role in Charles II's escape, attributing his survival to a broader network of support and good fortune. Some question the reliability of the source material and the romanticized portrayal of the events. Others highlight the importance of seemingly small actions in history and the potential for individuals to make a significant impact, even if not solely responsible for major outcomes. There's also discussion of the general tendency to simplify historical narratives and the challenges of reconstructing the past accurately.
A 500-year-old turret clock in the Oxfordshire village of Ewelme is still keeping time. Originally installed in St. Mary's Church around 1525, the clock is one of the oldest working clocks in England. It's powered by weights and requires weekly winding by a dedicated volunteer, and recent restoration work ensures it will continue ticking for generations to come. The clock's longevity is attributed to its robust construction and consistent maintenance throughout its history.
HN commenters discuss the clock's remarkable longevity and the dedication required to maintain it for five centuries. Some highlight the contrast between this historical artifact and modern disposable technology, lamenting the decline of craftsmanship and community engagement. Others focus on the technical aspects, speculating on the clock's mechanism and materials, and the challenges of its upkeep in different eras. A few express skepticism about the claimed 500-year continuous operation, suggesting periods of disrepair or replacement of parts are likely. There's also some debate about the actual age of the clock's components and the accuracy of its timekeeping over such a long period.
Newly discovered sections of an ancient wall in the Gobi Desert, initially thought to be the Great Wall of China, have been revealed to be a much older structure built by the Xiongnu people. Archaeological analysis, including drone mapping and radiocarbon dating of organic materials like reeds and wood, suggests the wall, constructed of local materials and featuring strategically placed watchtowers, dates back to the 1st century BCE. Researchers believe it served as a defensive barrier against rival tribes and potentially played a role in controlling trade routes. The discovery sheds light on the sophisticated engineering and organizational capabilities of the Xiongnu and challenges previous assumptions about the region's history.
HN commenters discuss the likelihood of the "Gobi Wall" being a natural formation rather than a man-made structure. Several suggest it's a common geological feature, possibly a dike, volcanic extrusion, or solidified lava flow exposed by erosion. Others point to the lack of consistent construction techniques and the implausibility of such a long wall in a harsh desert environment. Some highlight the wall's varying heights and materials as evidence against human construction, while others mention similar natural formations found elsewhere. A few express skepticism about the article's claims and the need for further investigation to determine the wall's true origin. Overall, the consensus leans towards a natural explanation, with commenters calling for more rigorous scientific analysis before jumping to conclusions about ancient civilizations.
Hong Kong's iconic bamboo scaffolding, a traditional building method prized for its speed, flexibility, and affordability, faces an uncertain future. While still prevalent, it's increasingly being replaced by metal scaffolding due to rising labor costs, stricter safety regulations, and a dwindling number of skilled bamboo scaffolders. Though some architects and preservationists champion bamboo's sustainability and cultural significance, its continued use in Hong Kong depends on addressing training gaps and adapting to modern building practices.
HN commenters largely discuss the ingenuity and practicality of bamboo scaffolding, praising its strength, flexibility, speed of construction, and sustainability compared to metal alternatives. Some note the skilled labor required and the cultural significance of this traditional method in Hong Kong. Several commenters express concern over the declining use of bamboo scaffolding due to rising labor costs and government regulations favoring metal, viewing this shift as a loss of a unique and efficient practice. A few commenters also share personal anecdotes of witnessing these structures in Hong Kong, emphasizing their impressive scale and artistry. The safety of bamboo scaffolding is also touched upon, with some arguing for its safety record when properly constructed and maintained.
Sam Kean's "Caesar's Last Breath" explores the fascinating interconnectedness of the air we breathe through history and science. The book uses the premise that we likely inhale some of the same molecules Julius Caesar exhaled in his dying breath to delve into the composition of air, its elements, and their roles in various historical events. From the Big Bang to modern pollution, Kean examines the impact of atmospheric gases on everything from the Hindenburg disaster to climate change, weaving together scientific principles with engaging anecdotes and historical narratives. The book ultimately reveals the surprising stories contained within the seemingly simple act of breathing.
HN commenters largely enjoyed the article, calling it "fascinating," "well-written," and "mind-blowing." Several expressed surprise at the idea that we might be inhaling molecules of Caesar's last breath, with one noting the sheer scale of diffusion and another pointing out the unlikelihood of a specific molecule making the journey unchanged. Some discussed the implications for other historical figures and events, wondering about shared molecules from other points in history or the potential for "sniffing history" through preserved air samples. A few commenters delved into the math and science behind the claim, discussing Avogadro's number, atmospheric mixing, and the probability of inhaling ancient molecules. One commenter offered a counterpoint, suggesting the constant creation and destruction of molecules might make the claim less compelling.
A persistent, though likely apocryphal, story claims an ancient law mandates a bale of hay (sometimes straw) be hung from Charing Cross railway bridge. This supposed law is often linked to a public execution or a builder's compensation for lost river access due to the bridge's construction. However, no evidence supports the existence of such a law, and its origins likely lie in humorous speculation and urban legend. The story's longevity is attributed to its amusing and intriguing nature, even without factual basis.
HN commenters discuss the curious law requiring a bale of hay to hang from Charing Cross bridge. Several express skepticism about the veracity of the "ancient law," with one pointing out the bridge's relatively young age (1864) and suggesting the story is likely apocryphal, perhaps a humorous anecdote started by a construction worker. Others question the practicality and safety of such a law, wondering about the frequency of replacement and potential fire hazard. The overall sentiment leans towards amusement and disbelief, with some appreciating the quirky nature of the story even if untrue. Some commenters also explore the possibility of it being a "jest" inserted into a contract or planning document, rather than an actual enforceable law.
Mused.com offers a text-to-3D historical simulation tool built on a map interface. Users input text descriptions of historical events, movements, or developments, and the platform generates a 3D visualization of those descriptions overlaid on a geographical map. This allows for an interactive exploration of history, showing the spatial and temporal relationships between events in a visually engaging way. The system is designed to handle complex historical narratives and aims to provide an intuitive way to understand and learn about the past.
HN users generally expressed interest in the project, with some praising the historical visualization aspect and the potential for educational uses. Several commenters questioned the accuracy and potential biases in the historical data used, particularly concerning the representation of indigenous populations and colonial history. Others discussed technical aspects, including the use of GPT-3, the choice of mapping library (Deck.gl), and the challenges of visualizing complex historical data effectively. There was also discussion of the project's potential for misuse, particularly in spreading misinformation or reinforcing existing biases. A few users suggested improvements, such as adding citation functionality and offering more granular controls over the visualized data. Overall, the comments reflect a mix of enthusiasm for the project's potential and cautious awareness of its limitations and potential pitfalls.
The post explores the differing perspectives on technological advancement, particularly AI. It contrasts the "seers," who grasp the transformative potential of these technologies and anticipate both the immense benefits and existential risks, with those who "cannot even look," either dismissing the technology's significance entirely or focusing narrowly on short-term impacts. The author argues this divide isn't about intelligence but imagination and the ability to extrapolate current trends to envision radical future possibilities. They emphasize the urgency of recognizing the potential for profound societal disruption and the need for proactive strategies to navigate the coming changes, suggesting that the future hinges on whether the "seers" can effectively communicate their vision to the wider society.
Hacker News users discussed the subjectivity of "seeing" and "looking," with several agreeing with the article's premise that some individuals engage more deeply with the world around them. Some commenters connected this idea to mindfulness and the ability to be present. Others attributed the difference to curiosity, experience, and knowledge, suggesting that expertise in a field allows for a deeper level of observation. A few debated the article's tone, finding it overly dramatic or even condescending. Some pushed back against the binary presented, arguing that "seeing" is a spectrum and everyone engages with the world differently. There was also discussion about the role of privilege and access in shaping one's ability to "see."
The blog post "Evolution of Rust Compiler Errors" traces the improvements in Rust's error messages over time. It highlights how early error messages were often cryptic and unhelpful, relying on internal compiler terminology. Through dedicated effort and community feedback, these messages evolved to become significantly more user-friendly. The post showcases specific examples of error transformations, demonstrating how improved diagnostics, contextual information like relevant code snippets, and helpful suggestions have made debugging Rust code considerably easier. This evolution reflects a continuous focus on improving the developer experience by making errors more understandable and actionable.
HN commenters largely praised the improvements to Rust's compiler errors, highlighting the journey from initially cryptic messages to the current, more helpful diagnostics. Several noted the significant impact of the error indexing initiative, allowing for easy online searching and community discussion around specific errors. Some expressed continued frustration with lifetime errors, while others pointed out that even improved errors can sometimes struggle with complex generic code. A few commenters compared Rust's error evolution favorably to other languages, particularly C++, emphasizing the proactive work done by the Rust community to improve developer experience. One commenter suggested potential future improvements, such as suggesting concrete fixes instead of just pointing out problems.
Pollen analysis reveals that chestnut trees experienced a boom and bust cycle mirroring the Roman Empire's trajectory. Widespread cultivation during Roman expansion, fueled by the chestnut's nutritional and construction value, led to its dominance over native oak forests. However, with the empire's decline, chestnut cultivation dwindled, allowing oak to regain its prominence. This ecological shift, visible in pollen records across Europe, demonstrates the profound impact Roman infrastructure and economic activity had on the landscape, highlighting how even seemingly natural environments can bear the imprint of human history.
Several commenters on Hacker News discussed the methodology of using chestnut pollen as a proxy for Roman influence, expressing skepticism about its accuracy and the strength of the causal link. Some highlighted the limitations of pollen studies, pointing to the potential for misinterpretation due to factors like wind dispersal and long-distance trade. Others debated the actual impact of the Roman Empire on chestnut cultivation, suggesting that existing cultivation practices might simply have been intensified, rather than introduced, by the Romans. The complexity of ecological and historical factors was emphasized, with some arguing for a more nuanced view of the relationship between chestnut distribution and Roman activity. A few commenters also shared additional historical context, including the role of chestnuts in pre-Roman societies and the impact of later historical events on chestnut populations.
The article "The Pigeon Whistle: A Defining Sound of Old Beijing" reminisces about the near-lost tradition of pigeon whistling, once a ubiquitous sound in Beijing's hutongs. These small, intricately carved whistles, attached to pigeons' tails, produced unique melodies as the birds flew, creating a symphony in the sky. The practice, dating back centuries, represented a unique blend of craftsmanship and cultural significance, reflecting the intimate connection between Beijingers and their avian companions. However, urbanization and changing lifestyles have led to a decline in pigeon keeping and whistle making, leaving the tradition on the verge of extinction, preserved only by a handful of dedicated enthusiasts.
HN commenters discuss the cultural significance of pigeon whistles in Old Beijing, lamenting their decline due to modernization and changing lifestyles. Some share personal anecdotes of hearing the whistles during their visits to Beijing, describing them as a unique and memorable auditory experience. Others detail the technical aspects of crafting and using the whistles, explaining how different designs and materials produce varied sounds. A few commenters note the pigeon whistles' similarity to other cultural practices around the world involving bird sounds, while others focus on the potential cruelty of attaching whistles to birds. The ethical implications of the practice are briefly touched upon. A general sense of nostalgia pervades the thread, with many expressing sadness that this aspect of traditional Beijing culture is fading away.
The moricons.dll file in Windows contains icons originally designed for Microsoft's abandoned "Cairo" operating system project. These icons weren't repurposed from existing applications but were newly created for Cairo's planned object-oriented filesystem and its associated utilities. While some icons depict generic concepts like folders and documents, others represent specific functionalities like object linking and embedding, security features, and mail messaging within the Cairo environment. Ultimately, since Cairo never shipped, these icons found a home in various dialogs and system tools within Windows 95 and later, often used as placeholders or for functionalities not explicitly designed for.
Hacker News users discuss the mystery surrounding the unused icons in moricons.dll, speculating about their purpose and the development process at Microsoft. Some suggest the icons were placeholders for future features or remnants of abandoned projects, possibly related to Cairo or object linking and embedding (OLE). One commenter links to a blog post claiming the icons were for a "Mac-on-DOS" environment called "Cougar," intended to make porting Macintosh software easier. Other comments focus on the general software development practice of leaving unused resources in code, attributing it to factors like time constraints, changing priorities, or simply forgetting to remove them. A few users recall encountering similar unused resources in other software, highlighting the commonality of this phenomenon.
BBC Culture highlights the 1915 novel The Thirty-Nine Steps by John Buchan as an overlooked masterpiece containing coded messages about World War I. While ostensibly a thriller, the book subtly reflects the anxieties and realities of the war, using landscape descriptions, character names, and plot points to allude to wartime strategies, spy networks, and the escalating conflict. Buchan, who worked in wartime propaganda, embedded these details, making the novel not just entertaining escapism but a coded reflection of the contemporary anxieties and a testament to his firsthand knowledge of the unfolding war.
Hacker News users discuss the BBC article about John Singer Sargent's painting "Gassed," focusing on its symbolism and the artist's personal connection to the war. Some commenters highlight the painting's powerful depiction of suffering and its subtle details, like the coded message in the arrangement of the soldiers' canes. Others debate the extent to which Sargent, known for his portraiture, truly captured the horrors of war, given his lack of frontline experience. Several users share additional historical context about Sargent's war commission and the impact of gas warfare, while others simply express their appreciation for the artwork and the article's insights. A few commenters also link to other resources, such as a higher resolution image of the painting and information about other war artists.
Analysis of animal bones recovered from a 16th-century Spanish shipwreck off the coast of Florida reveals the presence of a house cat, likely brought over as a pet. This discovery pushes back the estimated arrival of domesticated cats in what is now the United States by nearly a century, suggesting Europeans introduced them much earlier than previously thought. The cat's remains indicate it was smaller than typical European wildcats, supporting the idea it was a domesticated companion animal rather than a working cat used for pest control on the ship.
Hacker News users discuss the implications of a cat skeleton found on a 16th-century Spanish shipwreck off the coast of Florida, considered the earliest evidence of domesticated cats in the US. Several commenters question whether the cat was truly a "pet" or simply a ship's cat used for rodent control, highlighting the difficulty of determining the animal's exact role centuries later. Some discuss the history of cats in the Americas, suggesting earlier, undocumented introductions are possible. Others express skepticism about the "earliest known" claim, pointing to the potential for earlier, undiscovered remains. A few humorous comments lament the lack of internet access for the feline passenger and imagine its shipboard adventures. Overall, the discussion centers on the ambiguity surrounding the cat's purpose and the challenges of definitively labeling it a "pet" based on limited archaeological evidence.
Lin Yang Chen's post celebrates the enduring design of Malaya's stamps, particularly the 1948-1957 definitive series. Chen admires their balance of simplicity and detailed artistry, highlighting the carefully crafted typography, the intricate yet clear depiction of King George VI's portrait, and the understated yet effective background patterns. He contrasts this classic design with the perceived decline in aesthetic quality of many contemporary stamps, arguing that Malaya's stamps achieved a timeless elegance through careful consideration of typography, imagery, and overall composition, offering a lesson in effective graphic design that remains relevant today.
HN users largely praise the clean design and informative nature of the Malaya philately site. Several commenters appreciate the focus on content over flashy, distracting elements, finding it refreshing in the modern web landscape. The creator's approach of prioritizing a pleasant reading experience resonated with many. Some discuss technical aspects, including the choice of static site generator and image optimization techniques, expressing admiration for the efficient implementation. A few users share their own experiences with stamp collecting and website design, adding personal anecdotes to the discussion. One commenter points out a minor layout issue on mobile, but the overall sentiment is overwhelmingly positive.
Warren Robinett's Adventure, released in 1979 (not 1980 as the title suggests), for the Atari 2600, is a groundbreaking game considered the first action-adventure and the first to feature an "Easter egg" – Robinett's hidden signature. Developed despite Atari's policy of not crediting programmers, Adventure's simple graphics represented a fantasy world where players retrieved a jeweled chalice while navigating mazes, battling dragons, and interacting with objects like keys and bridges. Its open-world gameplay and multiple screens were innovative for the time, significantly influencing later game design. The game's success helped legitimize the role of programmers and contributed to the rise of the video game industry.
Commenters on Hacker News discussed the ingenuity of Warren Robinett hiding his name in the game "Adventure" given the corporate culture at Atari at the time, which didn't credit developers. Some recalled their childhood experiences discovering the Easter egg and the sense of mystery it evoked. Others debated the impact of "Adventure" on gaming history, with some arguing its significance in popularizing the action-adventure genre and others highlighting its technical achievements given the 2600's limitations. A few commenters also shared personal anecdotes about working with or meeting Robinett. One commenter even linked a video showing how to trigger the easter egg.
Switzerland's extensive bunker system, capable of sheltering its entire population plus some, stems from a long-standing tradition of neutrality and defensive preparedness. Facing potential threats throughout history, particularly during World War II and the Cold War, the Swiss government mandated the construction of private and public shelters to protect its citizens from attack. This commitment to national security, coupled with the country's mountainous terrain suitable for fortification, led to the development of this unique and comprehensive network of bunkers, ingrained in Swiss culture as a practical necessity.
HN commenters discuss the Swiss bunker system's history and practicality. Several point out that the system is a Cold War relic, designed to protect against a conventional Soviet invasion, not a modern nuclear attack. Some question the current value of the shelters, citing maintenance costs and the changed nature of warfare. Others argue that the bunkers, while potentially inadequate for a nuclear war, could still be useful in other scenarios like natural disasters or conventional conflicts. A few commenters with firsthand knowledge describe the bunkers' design and construction, including details about ventilation, supplies, and blast doors. The overall sentiment seems to be one of curiosity mixed with skepticism about the bunkers' present-day relevance.
In 1978, North Korean dictator Kim Jong-il kidnapped South Korean director Shin Sang-ok and his actress wife, Choi Eun-hee, to bolster the nation's film industry. Forced to work for Kim, Shin eventually directed Pulgasari, a North Korean Godzilla knockoff featuring a giant iron-eating monster that helps peasants revolt against a tyrannical king. Despite its propagandistic undertones, the film became a cult classic, showcasing impressive special effects for its time and a compelling story. Shin and Choi eventually escaped during a trip to Vienna in 1986, exposing their ordeal to the world.
HN commenters discuss the Vanity Fair article about the North Korean film Pulgasari, largely focusing on the bizarre circumstances of its production. Several express skepticism about the kidnapping narrative, questioning Shin Sang-ok's account and suggesting his "escape" might have been defection. Others highlight the film's unintentional camp value and the irony of a communist allegory featuring a Godzilla-like monster that consumes metal, representing the insatiable hunger of industry. Some commenters analyze the film's technical aspects, noting its surprisingly decent special effects for its time and budget constraints. A few share additional resources, including a documentary and a Shin Sang-ok interview, for those interested in learning more. The overall sentiment is one of fascination with this strange intersection of film, politics, and propaganda.
May Day's origins lie in the late 19th-century labor movement's fight for an eight-hour workday. Specifically, it commemorates the Haymarket Affair in Chicago, where workers protesting for shorter hours were met with police violence and a subsequent bombing, resulting in wrongful convictions and executions. The event galvanized international labor movements and, at the Second International's 1889 congress in Paris, May 1st was declared International Workers' Day in honor of the Haymarket martyrs and as a continuing call for the eight-hour workday. It became a day of demonstrations, strikes, and celebrations for workers' rights worldwide.
HN commenters discuss the history of May Day and its connection to the Haymarket affair. Some point out the common misconception that May Day commemorates the Haymarket bombing itself, rather than the broader movement for the eight-hour workday for which the executed anarchists were rallying. Others highlight the historical revisionism and propaganda surrounding the event, particularly the portrayal of the accused as violent agitators. A few users delve deeper into the specific legal aspects of the trial, emphasizing its unfairness and the lack of evidence linking the defendants to the bombing. The thread also briefly touches upon the international adoption of May Day as a workers' holiday and its subsequent evolution in different countries.
Forty years ago, in 1982, the author joined Sun Microsystems, a startup at the time with only about 40 employees. Initially hired as a technical writer, the author quickly transitioned into a marketing role focused on the Sun-1 workstation, learning about the technology alongside the engineers. This involved creating marketing materials like brochures and presentations, attending trade shows, and generally spreading the word about Sun's innovative workstation. The author reflects fondly on this exciting period of growth and innovation at Sun, emphasizing the close-knit and collaborative atmosphere of a small company making a big impact in the burgeoning computer industry.
HN commenters discuss the author's apparent naiveté about Sun's business practices, particularly regarding customer lock-in through proprietary hardware and software. Some recall Sun's early open-source friendliness contrasting with their later embrace of closed systems. Several commenters share anecdotes about their own experiences with Sun hardware and software, both positive and negative, highlighting the high cost and complexity, but also the power and innovation of their workstations. The thread also touches on the cultural shift in the tech industry since the 80s, noting the different expectations and pace of work. Finally, some express nostalgia for the era and the excitement surrounding Sun Microsystems.
The Lebanese Rocket Society, despite facing extreme adversity including war, economic collapse, and societal apathy, managed to launch Lebanon's first two rockets into space in the 1960s. Driven by a passionate team of university students and their professor, Manoug Manougian, they achieved this remarkable feat with limited resources and support, relying on ingenuity and a can-do attitude. Though ultimately unsustainable due to a lack of government and public interest coupled with regional instability, the program serves as a powerful testament to the potential for innovation and achievement even in the most challenging circumstances. It highlights the importance of vision, dedication, and resourcefulness in pursuing ambitious goals.
HN commenters generally praised the article for its engaging storytelling and the inspiring, albeit ultimately tragic, depiction of the Lebanese rocket society. Several pointed out the parallels to other "amateur" space programs and the importance of such endeavors, even if they don't achieve their ultimate goals. Some discussed the political and economic context of Lebanon in the 1960s, contributing to the understanding of the program's rise and fall. A few questioned the ultimate fate of the Cedar rockets and whether any documentation or physical remnants still exist. The most compelling comments focused on the human element of the story, emphasizing the passion and dedication of Manoug Manougian and his team in the face of overwhelming odds.
The blog post explores the history of Apple's rumored adoption of ZFS, the advanced file system. While Apple engineers internally prototyped and tested ZFS integration, ultimately licensing and legal complexities, combined with performance concerns specific to Apple's hardware (particularly flash storage) and the desire for full control over the file system's development, prevented its official adoption. Though ZFS offered appealing features, Apple chose to focus on its own in-house solutions, culminating in APFS. The post debunks claims of a fully functioning "ready to ship" ZFS implementation within OS X 10.5, clarifying it was experimental and never intended for release.
HN commenters discuss Apple's exploration and ultimate rejection of ZFS. Some highlight the licensing incompatibility as the primary roadblock, with ZFS's CDDL clashing with Apple's restrictive approach. Others speculate about Apple's internal politics and the potential "not invented here" syndrome influencing the decision. A few express disappointment, believing ZFS would have significantly benefited macOS, while some counter that APFS, Apple's eventual solution, adequately addresses their needs. The potential performance implications of ZFS on Apple hardware are also debated, with some arguing that Apple's hardware is uniquely suited to ZFS's strengths. Finally, the technical challenges of integrating ZFS, especially regarding snapshots and Time Machine, are mentioned as potential reasons for Apple's decision.
In the Age of Sail, beer was a crucial provision aboard ships, offering a safe and nutritious alternative to potentially contaminated water. Brewed with a high alcohol content and hopped for preservation, it could last for months at sea, preventing scurvy and providing vital calories. While officers often enjoyed wine and spirits, beer was the everyday beverage for sailors, issued in daily rations and contributing significantly to morale. Records from the USS Constitution illustrate the logistics and importance of beer in naval operations, showing how large quantities were purchased, stored, and distributed to the crew. The practice eventually declined with improvements in water purification and the rise of temperance movements.
Commenters on Hacker News largely discuss the historical accuracy and practicality of beer as a staple drink on sailing vessels. Several point out the importance of beer as a safe beverage alternative to potentially contaminated water, emphasizing its role in preventing scurvy via its small vitamin C content (though not enough for full prevention) and its boiling process which killed harmful bacteria. Some commenters debate the alcoholic content of these historical beers, suggesting they were likely "small beer" with a lower ABV, making them more hydrating than modern-day equivalents. Others discuss the logistics of storage and preservation, such as the use of tightly sealed barrels to prevent spoilage. A few comments also touch upon the cultural significance of beer rations and their importance for morale amongst sailors.
"The Ghosts of Gaelic" explores the decline of the Gaelic languages (Irish, Scottish Gaelic, and Manx) by examining the social and political forces that suppressed them. The article highlights the impact of English colonialism, the rise of English as the language of commerce and education, and the devastating effects of the Highland Clearances and the Great Famine. While acknowledging the significant loss of speakers and cultural heritage, it also points to the enduring presence of Gaelic, evident in revived interest, language learning initiatives, and ongoing efforts to preserve and promote these languages within their respective communities. Ultimately, the article frames the story of Gaelic not as one of simple demise, but rather as a complex narrative of resilience and adaptation in the face of historical adversity.
HN users discuss the decline of Gaelic, attributing it to factors beyond just English suppression. Some highlight the internal social dynamics within Gaelic communities, where upward mobility was linked to English adoption. Others mention the role of the printing press in standardizing and solidifying English's dominance, while the lack of a similar effort for Gaelic hindered its survival. The role of religion, specifically Protestant evangelism promoting English literacy, is also pointed out. Finally, some commenters compare the situation to other minority languages, noting similar patterns of decline and emphasizing the complex interplay of social, economic, and political factors. One compelling argument suggests that language preservation requires more than just government funding or language nests, needing robust everyday use and cultural relevance to thrive. Another notes the parallels with how Latin faded as a vernacular language.
In 1825, scientific inquiry spanned diverse fields. Researchers explored the luminous properties of rotting wood, the use of chlorine in bleaching, and the composition of various minerals and chemicals like iodine and uric acid. Advances in practical applications included improvements to printing, gas lighting, and the construction of canal locks. Scientific understanding also progressed in areas like electromagnetism, with Ampère refining his theories, and astronomy, with studies on planetary orbits. This snapshot of 1825 reveals a period of active exploration and development across both theoretical and practical sciences.
HN commenters were impressed by the volume and breadth of research from 1825, highlighting how much scientific progress was being made even then. Several noted the irony of calling the list "incomplete," given its already extensive nature. Some pointed out specific entries of interest, such as work on electromagnetism and the speed of sound. A few users discussed the context of the time, including the limited communication infrastructure and the relative youth of many researchers. The rudimentary nature of some experiments, compared to modern standards, was also observed, emphasizing the ingenuity required to achieve results with limited tools.
This article explores how mathematics, specifically statistics and probability, were manipulated in Nazi Germany to promote racist ideologies and justify discriminatory policies. It examines how seemingly objective mathematical concepts were twisted and selectively applied to create a false sense of scientific backing for eugenic programs and the persecution of minorities. By focusing on skewed data and misrepresenting statistical concepts, the Nazi regime aimed to convince the public of the inferiority of certain groups, thereby normalizing and legitimizing their horrific actions. The article serves as a warning about the potential for mathematical tools to be misused in the service of dangerous ideologies.
Hacker News users discuss the role of mathematics in Nazi Germany, focusing on how mathematical skill and logic were twisted to serve a hateful ideology. Some commenters point out the danger of believing that intelligence or technical proficiency inherently leads to morality, highlighting how easily logic can be applied to justify horrific acts. Others discuss the specific examples in the article, like Bieberbach's attempts to define "German mathematics" and the expulsion of Jewish mathematicians, illustrating the devastating impact of such politicization. Several users express concern about the potential for similar abuses of science and reason in the present day, warning against complacency. There's also a brief thread on the general difficulty of defining "national" characteristics in fields like mathematics, with some arguing that it's inherently a universal pursuit.
Despite its association with the crucifixion of Jesus, Good Friday is called "good" for a few possible reasons. "Good" may be a corruption of "God Friday," or reflect the older sense of "holy." Alternatively, it may refer to the belief that Christ's death, while tragic, ultimately brought salvation to humanity, therefore making it a "good" event. Finally, some suggest "good" refers to the good deeds performed by Christ throughout his life, culminating in his ultimate sacrifice.
Several Hacker News commenters discuss the etymology of "Good Friday," with most agreeing that "good" likely derives from archaic usages meaning "holy" or "pious." Some suggest alternative theories, like "God's Friday," but these are generally dismissed. One commenter points out the irony of calling a day commemorating a crucifixion "good." Another highlights regional variations in how the day is named, citing "Great Friday" in some areas. A few commenters lament the increasingly secular nature of modern society and the declining awareness of religious terminology and traditions. There's also a brief tangent discussing linguistic shifts and the evolution of word meanings over time.
WhichYear.com presents a visual guessing game challenging users to identify the year a photograph was taken. The site displays a photo and provides four year choices as possible answers. After selecting an answer, the correct year is revealed along with a brief explanation of the visual clues that point to that era. The game spans a wide range of photographic subjects and historical periods, testing players' knowledge of fashion, technology, and cultural trends.
HN users generally found the "Which Year" game fun and well-executed, praising its simple yet engaging concept. Several commenters discussed the subtle cues they used to pinpoint the year, such as fashion trends, car models, image quality, and the presence or absence of digital artifacts. Some noted the difficulty increased with more recent years due to the faster pace of technological advancement and stylistic changes, while others appreciated the nostalgic trip through time. A few users shared their scores and playfully lamented their inability to distinguish between certain decades. The addictive nature of the game was a recurring theme, with some admitting they spent more time playing than intended. One commenter suggested adding a difficulty slider, while another expressed their enjoyment at being able to recognize specific cameras used in some photos.
Oda Ujiharu, a Sengoku-era warlord often dubbed the "weakest," is surprisingly remembered fondly in Japan, not for military prowess, but for his peaceful and clever governance. Faced with the overwhelming power of Oda Nobunaga, Ujiharu recognized his inevitable defeat and prioritized the well-being of his people. Instead of futile resistance, he negotiated surrender terms that preserved their lives and livelihoods, even securing a comfortable retirement for himself. This act of selflessness and pragmatic leadership, prioritizing his people over personal glory, cemented his legacy as a benevolent and wise ruler, a stark contrast to the era's often brutal warlords.
HN commenters generally found the story of Oda Ujiharu heartwarming and appreciated learning about a historical figure who prioritized his people's well-being over personal glory. Several highlighted the contrast between Ujiharu's compassionate leadership and the typical ruthlessness often associated with warlords. Some debated the accuracy of the "weakest" label, arguing that his pragmatic choices demonstrated strength and wisdom. A few commenters also pointed out the story's relevance to modern leadership and its potential lessons for business and management. One compelling comment suggested that Ujiharu's enduring popularity stems from a cultural appreciation for humility and the quiet strength of choosing peace, especially in a society that historically valued martial prowess. Another insightful comment connected Ujiharu's actions to the concept of "noblesse oblige," arguing that his sense of responsibility towards his people drove his decisions.
Summary of Comments ( 5 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44127177
HN commenters were fascinated by the 3D stereograph photos of the Civil War, expressing surprise at the technology's existence during that era. Several pointed out the haunting and surreal nature of seeing such a destructive period in 3D, making it feel more immediate and real. Some discussed the technical aspects of stereoscopic photography and the challenges of capturing such images during the war. A few commenters also shared additional resources related to Civil War photography and 3D imagery. The overall sentiment was one of awe and appreciation for the historical significance and technological ingenuity of these photographs.
The Hacker News post linking to the New-York Historical Society's blog post about Civil War stereographs has a modest number of comments, offering a few different perspectives on the topic.
Several comments focus on the technical aspects of stereoscopic photography. One user points out the surprising sophistication of 19th-century lens manufacturing, highlighting that achieving good stereo pairs requires carefully matched lenses. Another commenter discusses the experience of viewing stereographs, noting the sometimes unsettling feeling of unreality or artificiality they can produce. This commenter also mentions the surprisingly long history of 3D viewing technology, referencing Sir Charles Wheatstone's work in the 1830s. Another comment thread discusses the various viewing methods, including handheld stereoscopes, Holmes stereoscopes, and free-viewing techniques.
Some comments touch upon the historical significance of the images. One commenter notes the eerie feeling of looking into the past and seeing the faces of individuals who lived through such a pivotal moment in American history. Another reflects on the impact of the Civil War and how these images offer a glimpse into that era.
A couple of comments offer additional resources. One user links to a collection of Civil War stereographs on Flickr, providing further opportunity to explore this type of photography. Another links to a resource about the history of stereo photography, broadening the context beyond the Civil War.
Finally, one comment humorously remarks on the ubiquity of 3D technology hype cycles, suggesting that the interest in 3D imaging is a recurring phenomenon.
While not a large number of comments, they offer a mix of technical insights, historical reflections, and further avenues for exploration related to stereoscopic photography and the Civil War.