This photo essay showcases Chongqing, a sprawling metropolis in southwest China. The images capture the city's unique blend of mountainous terrain and dense urban development, highlighting its layered infrastructure, including towering skyscrapers, bridges crisscrossing rivers and valleys, and a bustling port. The photographs also offer glimpses into daily life, depicting crowded streets, traditional architecture alongside modern buildings, and the city's vibrant energy.
This Guardian photo essay, titled "Chongqing, the Largest City – In Pictures," offers a visually compelling glimpse into the sprawling metropolis of Chongqing, China, a municipality often cited as the world's largest by population. The photographs depict a city of striking contrasts and remarkable scale, showcasing its unique geographic and urban characteristics. We are presented with images of towering skyscrapers piercing the fog that frequently blankets the city, a testament to its rapid modernization and vertical growth. These modern structures are juxtaposed with scenes of traditional life, emphasizing the coexistence of the old and new within this bustling urban landscape. The photographs capture the density of the city's population, illustrated by crowded streets and packed public transportation. The mountainous terrain upon which Chongqing is built is a prominent feature in many of the images, with buildings seemingly clinging to steep hillsides and bridges spanning dramatic valleys carved by the Yangtze and Jialing Rivers. This challenging topography has shaped the city's development, influencing its transportation systems, including a prominent monorail system that navigates the complex cityscape, and contributing to its layered, three-dimensional urban form. The photographs also highlight the city's vibrant street life, depicting street vendors, bustling marketplaces, and the daily activities of its inhabitants. From bustling commercial centers to quiet residential areas, the essay provides a diverse visual narrative of Chongqing, illustrating the multifaceted nature of this mega-city and offering a glimpse into the lives of the millions who call it home. The photographs effectively capture the energy and dynamism of this rapidly evolving metropolis, showcasing its unique blend of natural beauty, architectural innovation, and the enduring spirit of its people.
Summary of Comments ( 109 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43809915
Hacker News users discuss the impressive scale and visual impact of Chongqing, depicted in The Guardian's photo series. Several commenters express fascination with the city's unique geography and density, with its mountainous terrain and towering skyscrapers. Some debate the definition of "largest city," distinguishing between metropolitan area and city proper populations. Others highlight the article's striking visuals, particularly the layering of infrastructure and buildings clinging to the hillsides. A few commenters also mention Chongqing's historical significance and rapid development. The overall sentiment reflects awe and curiosity about this lesser-known megacity.
The Hacker News post titled "Chongqing, the Largest City – In Pictures" has a modest number of comments, generating a brief discussion around the definition of "largest city" and some observations about the photographs.
Several commenters take issue with The Guardian's claim of Chongqing being the world's largest city. They point out that the 30+ million figure often cited for Chongqing includes a large surrounding metropolitan area or administrative region, not just the urban population. Comparisons are made to other large urban agglomerations, such as the Pearl River Delta and Tokyo, with commenters arguing for different metrics to determine true "largest city" status. One commenter specifically highlights how city size definitions vary widely and suggests that land area should not be a primary factor. The discussion revolves around the distinction between a city proper, a metropolitan area, and an administrative region.
Some commenters focus on the photographs themselves, describing them as "beautiful" and "dystopian" simultaneously. They remark on the impressive scale and density of the city as depicted in the images. One commenter expresses a desire to visit Chongqing based on the striking visuals.
One commenter shares a personal anecdote, mentioning their time spent in Chongqing and confirming the impressive scale of the urban environment, noting the seemingly endless expanse of high-rise buildings. They also observe the city's unique topography and the way the buildings climb up the surrounding hills.
The overall tone of the comments is one of mild skepticism towards the headline's claim and appreciation for the photographic portrayal of Chongqing's urban landscape. While not extensive, the comments provide some context and perspective on the article's subject matter.