The cg_clif project has made significant progress in compiling Rust to C, achieving a 95.9% pass rate on the Rust test suite. This compiler leverages Cranelift as a backend and utilizes a custom ABI for passing Rust data structures. Notably, it's now functional on more unusual platforms like wasm32-wasi and thumbv6m-none-eabi (for embedded ARM devices). While performance isn't a primary focus currently, basic functionality and compatibility are progressing rapidly, demonstrating the potential for compiling Rust to a portable C representation.
The Game Boy Advance (GBA) holds a special place in gaming history, offering a perfect blend of portability, affordability, and a vast library of incredible games. The author reminisces fondly about their childhood experiences with the console, highlighting its sturdy design, the satisfying click of the buttons, and the immersive world it opened up through titles like Pokémon Ruby, Metroid Fusion, and The Legend of Zelda: The Minish Cap. The GBA served as a gateway to RPGs and fostered a lifelong love for gaming, representing a golden age of handheld consoles that remains unmatched even by today's technologically superior devices. Its impact was not just about the technology, but the memories and formative experiences it provided, making it more than just a gaming device, but a cherished piece of personal history.
Hacker News users fondly recall the Game Boy Advance, praising its perfect size, durable build, and the vast library of quality games. Several commenters highlight the backlit GBA SP as a pivotal upgrade, while others discuss favorite titles like Metroid Fusion, Advance Wars, and the various Pokemon games. The modding scene is also mentioned, with users discussing using flash carts to play ROMs and other homebrew software. Some lament the decline of dedicated handheld gaming devices and the rise of mobile gaming, contrasting the tactile experience and focused gameplay of the GBA with the more distracting nature of smartphones. There's a general consensus that the GBA represents a golden age of handheld gaming.
Summary of Comments ( 164 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43661329
Hacker News users discussed the impressive 95.9% test pass rate of the Rust-to-C compiler, particularly its ability to target unusual platforms like the Sega Saturn and Sony PlayStation. Some expressed skepticism about the practical applications, questioning the performance implications and debugging challenges of such a complex transpilation process. Others highlighted the potential benefits for code reuse and portability, enabling Rust code to run on legacy or resource-constrained systems. The project's novelty and ambition were generally praised, with several commenters expressing interest in the developer's approach and future developments. Some also debated the suitability of "compiler" versus "transpiler" to describe the project. There was also discussion around specific technical aspects, like memory management and the handling of Rust's borrow checker within the C output.
The Hacker News post titled "Rust to C compiler – 95.9% test pass rate, odd platforms" sparked a discussion with several interesting comments. Many commenters focused on the complexities and nuances of compiling Rust to C, particularly given Rust's unique memory management features.
One commenter highlighted the challenges inherent in translating Rust's borrow checker and ownership model into C, which lacks these built-in mechanisms. They questioned how the compiler handled these crucial aspects of Rust, expressing skepticism about achieving true compatibility without significant runtime overhead or limitations. This comment resonated with others who also expressed concern about the potential performance implications and the difficulty of replicating Rust's safety guarantees in C.
Another commenter pointed out the inherent difficulty in targeting "odd platforms," as mentioned in the title. They elaborated on the potential issues with varying C standard library implementations and the complexities of ensuring compatibility across diverse architectures and operating systems. This prompted a discussion about the trade-offs between portability and performance when attempting such a compilation process.
Several comments also touched on the potential use cases of such a compiler. Some suggested it could be valuable for embedded systems or environments where Rust isn't directly supported. Others questioned the practicality, arguing that if the target platform supports a C compiler, it might also be feasible to support a Rust compiler directly, potentially negating the need for a transpilation step.
The discussion also explored alternative approaches, such as compiling Rust to LLVM bitcode and then using LLVM to generate C code. This was presented as a potentially more robust approach that could leverage LLVM's optimizations and platform support.
Finally, some comments expressed interest in the specific platforms targeted by the project and requested more details about the remaining 4.1% of failing tests. They were curious about the nature of these failures and whether they represented fundamental limitations or solvable issues. Overall, the comments reflected a mixture of curiosity, skepticism, and cautious optimism about the potential of a Rust-to-C compiler.