Researchers have built a 32-bit RISC-V processor using a monolayer of molybdenum disulfide (MoS₂), a two-dimensional semiconductor. This achievement demonstrates the potential of 2D materials for creating extremely thin and energy-efficient transistors, pushing the boundaries of Moore's Law. While slower and larger than state-of-the-art silicon chips, this prototype represents a significant step towards practical applications of 2D semiconductors in computing. The processor, dubbed RV16XNano, successfully executed instructions and represents a promising foundation for future development of more complex and powerful 2D-material-based circuits.
The Bucket Brigade Device (BBD) is an analog shift register implemented using a chain of capacitors and transistors. It stores analog signals as charge packets on these capacitors, sequentially transferring them along the chain with the help of a clock signal. This creates a time delay proportional to the number of stages in the brigade. BBDs were historically used for audio effects like delay, chorus, and reverberation because of their simplicity and relatively low cost. However, they suffer from signal degradation due to charge leakage and require careful biasing and clocking for optimal performance. Despite being largely superseded by digital technologies, BBDs offer a fascinating example of analog signal processing.
HN users generally found the bucket brigade device fascinating. Several commenters discussed practical applications like its use in early audio delay lines and the challenges of clocking it consistently. Others appreciated the clear explanation and visualization of the device's operation, highlighting its simplicity and elegance. Some compared it to charge-coupled devices (CCDs) and discussed their similarities and differences in functionality and implementation. The practicality of using actual buckets filled with water was also debated, with some suggesting the analogy, while visually appealing, might not accurately represent the underlying physics of the electronic device. A few users linked to relevant Wikipedia pages and other resources for further exploration.
Summary of Comments ( 39 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43621378
Hacker News users discuss the implications of a RISC-V processor built with a 2D semiconductor. Several express excitement about the potential for flexible electronics and extremely low power consumption, envisioning applications in wearables and IoT devices. Some question the practicality due to the current limitations in clock speed and memory integration, while others point out the significant achievement of creating a functional processor with this technology at all. A few commenters delve into the specifics of the fabrication process and the challenges of scaling this technology for commercial production. Concerns about the fragility of the material and the potential difficulty in handling and packaging are also raised. Overall, the sentiment leans towards cautious optimism about the long-term possibilities of 2D semiconductors in computing.
The Hacker News post "A 32-bit processor made with an atomically thin semiconductor" discussing an Ars Technica article about a RISC-V processor built using a 2D semiconductor, generated a moderate number of comments, many of which delve into the technical details and potential implications of the research.
Several commenters focused on the performance aspects. One noted the extremely low clock speed (1 kHz) and questioned the practical applications given this limitation. Another commenter built on this, explaining that the low clock speed is likely due to the high resistance of the thin semiconductor material. They further elaborated that while the transistor density could theoretically be much higher, the interconnect resistance would become a bottleneck.
The discussion also touched upon the challenges of manufacturing and scaling this technology. A commenter pointed out that creating larger, more complex chips using this 2D material would be difficult due to defects. They questioned whether it would be possible to scale this to create a commercially viable product. Another commenter highlighted the specific challenges in achieving uniformity and consistency in a large-scale manufacturing process for atomically thin materials.
The potential advantages of 2D semiconductors were also discussed. One commenter mentioned the possibility of flexible electronics, suggesting that this technology could pave the way for devices that are bendable or even foldable. Another commenter mentioned potential applications in areas where power consumption is extremely important since reducing the thickness to the atomic level can impact a device's energy requirements.
Some comments delved into the specifics of the RISC-V architecture. One commenter pointed out that while the processor is a 32-bit RISC-V design, it lacks features commonly found in modern processors, making it more of a proof-of-concept rather than a practical processor.
Finally, a few commenters expressed skepticism, suggesting that this research, while interesting, is a long way from commercial viability. They emphasized that the current limitations in performance and manufacturing make it unlikely to replace existing silicon technology in the near future.
In summary, the comments section explored the technical complexities, potential benefits, and significant challenges associated with using 2D semiconductors for processor design. While excitement was expressed for the potential of this technology, many commenters remained realistic about the long road ahead for commercialization.