Captrice is a guitar practice app designed for serious players looking to improve their skills through deliberate practice. It offers a structured approach, allowing users to isolate and loop sections of music, slow them down, and meticulously work on specific techniques. The app supports various audio formats and integrates with cloud storage services for easy access to practice material. Captrice emphasizes efficient, focused practice, aiming to help guitarists of all levels refine their playing and reach their full potential.
"Notes" is an iOS app designed to help musicians improve their sight-reading skills. Available on the App Store for 10 years, the app presents users with randomly generated musical notation, covering a range of clefs, key signatures, and rhythms. Users can customize the difficulty level, focusing on specific areas for improvement. The app provides instant feedback on accuracy and tracks progress over time, helping musicians develop their ability to quickly and accurately interpret and play music.
HN users discussed the app's longevity and the developer's persistence, praising the 10-year milestone. Some shared their personal sight-reading practice methods, including using apps like Functional Ear Trainer and various websites. A few users suggested potential improvements for the app, such as adding support for other instruments beyond piano and offering more customization options like adjustable clefs. Others questioned the efficacy of pure note-reading practice without rhythmic context. The overall sentiment was positive, acknowledging the app's niche and the developer's commitment.
Summary of Comments ( 98 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43512470
HN users generally express interest in the app, praising its focus on deliberate practice and structured learning for guitar. Several commenters discuss the importance of targeted practice over aimless noodling, echoing the app's philosophy. Some express skepticism about the app's ability to cater to diverse learning styles and musical goals, wondering if it's too rigid. The desire for features like rhythm training and ear training is also mentioned. A few experienced guitarists question the long-term value proposition, suggesting that existing resources like books and transcription might be more beneficial. Overall, there's a mix of cautious optimism and pragmatic doubt regarding the app's effectiveness.
The Hacker News post "A deliberate practice app for guitar players who want to level up" (linking to caprice.io) generated a modest amount of discussion, with several commenters sharing their perspectives and experiences.
A recurring theme in the comments is the challenge of balancing structured practice with the joy of freely playing and exploring music. One commenter articulates this tension, explaining that while deliberate practice is crucial for targeted improvement, it can sometimes feel like a chore, contrasting with the inherent pleasure of improvising and jamming. They emphasize the importance of finding a balance that allows for both disciplined skill development and the creative expression that fuels passion for music.
Several commenters discuss existing tools and methods they use for deliberate practice, mentioning software like Transcribe! and looping pedals. These comments provide context for how guitarists currently approach focused practice and suggest that there's a pre-existing desire for tools that aid in this process. One commenter specifically points out the value of slow, focused practice, a principle that Captric seems designed to support.
Some commenters express skepticism about the app's potential impact. One questions whether the software truly addresses the core challenges of practicing guitar effectively. They imply that the app might offer a structured approach but might not be sufficient to motivate consistent and productive practice, which is ultimately the key to improvement. Another commenter, while not dismissing the app entirely, suggests that dedicated practice with a metronome might be just as effective, highlighting the importance of fundamental practice techniques.
Another commenter raises the concern that focusing too much on technical exercises can be detrimental to musicality and enjoyment. They advocate for a more holistic approach to learning, suggesting that prioritizing music theory and ear training alongside technical practice is essential for becoming a well-rounded musician.
Finally, a few commenters express interest in the app and its features, with some specifically asking about support for bass guitar, indicating a potential user base beyond just guitarists. Another commenter requests a lifetime pricing option, showing interest in a long-term commitment to the platform.
Overall, the comments reflect a mix of cautious optimism, skepticism, and practical considerations regarding the challenges and approaches to deliberate practice for musicians. While some see potential in Captric as a tool to aid focused practice, others emphasize the importance of balancing structured exercises with the creative aspects of playing music and question whether an app alone can address the complexities of skill development.