The 2005 Sony Bravia advertisement, famous for its vibrant depiction of 250,000 bouncing rubber balls cascading down a San Francisco hill, was a significant cultural moment. Shot on location over several days, the ad aimed to showcase the vivid color capabilities of the new Bravia televisions. While digitally enhanced to add more balls and smooth out imperfections, the core of the ad used practical effects, relying on the natural bounce and movement of the balls. Its production involved meticulous planning, street closures, and the collaboration of numerous artists and technicians. The ad became a sensation, boosting Sony's brand and inspiring numerous imitations.
This 1957 video demonstrates Walt Disney's groundbreaking multiplane camera. It showcases how the camera system, through a series of vertically stacked panes of glass holding artwork and lights, creates a sense of depth and parallax in animation. By moving the different layers at varying speeds and distances from the camera, Disney's animators achieved a more realistic and immersive three-dimensional effect, particularly noticeable in background scenes like forests and cityscapes. The video highlights the technical complexity of the camera and its impact on achieving a unique visual style, particularly in films like "Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs" and "Pinocchio."
The Hacker News comments on the Walt Disney multiplane camera video largely express appreciation for the ingenuity and artistry of the technique. Several commenters note how the depth and parallax achieved by the multiplane camera adds a significant level of realism and immersion compared to traditional animation. Some discuss the meticulous work involved, highlighting the challenges of synchronizing the multiple layers and the sheer amount of artwork required. A few comments mention the influence of this technique on later filmmaking, including its digital descendants in modern CGI and visual effects. Others reminisce about seeing Disney films as children and the impact the multiplane camera's visual richness had on their experience.
Summary of Comments ( 112 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43344129
HN commenters largely discuss the effectiveness and memorability of the Bravia ad, with many recalling it vividly years later. Some analyze the technical aspects of its production, noting the lack of CGI and the challenges of shooting with 250,000 bouncy balls. Several compare it favorably to modern advertising, lamenting the perceived decline in creativity and impact. A few users question the practicality and cost of the ad, while others share anecdotes about similar projects or express skepticism about its authenticity. The overall sentiment is one of appreciation for the ad's unique and engaging approach.
The Hacker News comments section for the post titled "The 2005 Sony Bravia ad" discusses the iconic commercial featuring 250,000 bouncing balls rolling down the streets of San Francisco. Several commenters reminisce about the ad's impact and its technical aspects.
One compelling comment thread focuses on the logistical challenges and the behind-the-scenes making of the commercial. Users discuss the use of CGI versus practical effects, with some correctly pointing out that while CGI was used for touch-ups and impossible shots, the vast majority of the bouncing balls were real. The discussion delves into the complexities of managing so many balls, including considerations about wind, ball retrieval, and potential damage to the environment. Some express admiration for the production team's effort in capturing such a visually stunning sequence practically.
Another thread centers on the effectiveness of the advertisement itself. Some commenters question the ad's memorability and its connection to the Sony Bravia brand. While acknowledging the visual spectacle, they argue that it didn't effectively communicate the product's features or benefits. Others counter this, stating the ad created a strong emotional connection with viewers, associating the brand with vibrant colors and a sense of playfulness, which ultimately boosted brand awareness. The discussion touches upon the difference between ads that focus on technical specifications versus those that aim for a more emotional and artistic impact.
A few comments also mention the ad's music, José González's cover of "Heartbeats," and its role in the commercial's overall success. They highlight the song's melancholic yet uplifting tone, which complements the visuals beautifully.
Finally, some users share their personal memories associated with the ad, recalling where they first saw it and the impression it left on them. These comments reflect the ad's cultural impact and its ability to evoke nostalgia. There's a sense of shared experience among those who remember the ad fondly.