A 2,200-year-old pyramid-shaped structure has been discovered near the Dead Sea in Israel. Dating back to the Hellenistic period, the structure contained hundreds of bronze coins, lead sling stones, iron weapon parts, and pottery fragments. Archaeologists believe it may be a fortified watchtower or military installation related to unrest during the reign of the Seleucid Empire. Its unusual pyramid shape and the presence of weapons suggest a connection to military activity, possibly related to conflicts between the Seleucids and the Ptolemaic kingdom or local revolts. Further excavation is needed to fully understand the structure's purpose and significance.
The blog post explores the interconnectedness of various measurement systems and mathematical concepts, examining potential historical links that are likely coincidental. The author notes the near equivalence of a meter to a royal cubit times the golden ratio, and how this relates to the dimensions of the Great Pyramid of Giza. While acknowledging the established historical definition of the meter based on Earth's circumference, the post speculates on whether ancient Egyptians might have possessed a sophisticated understanding of these relationships, potentially incorporating the golden ratio and Earth's dimensions into their construction. However, the author ultimately concludes that the observed connections are likely due to mathematical happenstance rather than deliberate design.
HN commenters largely dismiss the linked article as numerology and pseudoscience. Several point out the arbitrary nature of choosing specific measurements and units (meters, cubits) to force connections. One commenter notes that the golden ratio shows up frequently in geometric constructions, making its presence in the pyramids unsurprising and not necessarily indicative of intentional design. Others criticize the article's lack of rigor and its reliance on coincidences rather than evidence-based arguments. The general consensus is that the article presents a flawed and unconvincing argument for a relationship between these different elements.
Summary of Comments ( 4 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43507176
Hacker News commenters express skepticism about the "pyramid" designation, pointing out that the structure appears to be a heavily eroded square tower, more akin to a ziggurat than an Egyptian pyramid. They also question the sensationalized reporting, noting the lack of images of the actual coins and weapons, and the vague description of the finds. Some users highlight the complex history of the region and suggest possible connections to various historical groups, while others bemoan the clickbait-y nature of the original article title. Several commenters call for more rigorous reporting and better sourcing, with links to academic papers or archaeological reports preferred over popular science articles.
The Hacker News post titled "2,200-year-old pyramid filled with coins and weapons found near Dead Sea" has generated several comments discussing various aspects of the discovery.
Some users expressed skepticism about the use of the term "pyramid" to describe the structure, pointing out its stepped, ziggurat-like appearance. They suggest terms like "stepped platform" or "ziggurat" would be more accurate. This sparked a short discussion about the etymology and usage of the word "pyramid," with some users defending its broader application.
Several commenters questioned the claim that the structure was "filled" with coins and weapons, noting the article mentions only a "small number" of coins and sling stones. They expressed disappointment at the sensationalized headline and the lack of detailed information about the findings.
One commenter highlighted the historical context of the discovery, linking it to the Hasmonean period and suggesting a possible connection to the fortress of Mezad Hashavyahu. This sparked a discussion about the political landscape of the region during that time and the possible purpose of the structure, with theories ranging from military outpost to religious site.
A few commenters focused on the preservation of the site, expressing concern about looting and the importance of proper archaeological investigation. They discussed the challenges of protecting historical sites in conflict zones and the need for international collaboration.
Finally, some users commented on the fascinating nature of archaeological discoveries in general, expressing their excitement about learning more about the past and the mysteries it holds. They also discussed the importance of continued research and the potential for future discoveries in the region.
In summary, the comments on Hacker News reflect a mix of skepticism about the article's presentation, genuine curiosity about the historical context of the discovery, and a broader appreciation for the field of archaeology. The most compelling comments offer historical context, challenge the article's wording, and express concern about the site's preservation.