Researchers analyzed the unusually well-preserved brain of a victim of the Vesuvius eruption in Herculaneum. They discovered glassy, vitrified material within the skull, which they identified as human brain tissue transformed through extreme heat. This vitrification, likely caused by rapid heating and then cooling, preserved proteins and fatty acids normally destroyed by decay, offering a unique glimpse into ancient human brain biochemistry. This unprecedented finding provides evidence supporting the extreme temperatures reached during the eruption and demonstrates a unique preservation mechanism for organic material in archaeological contexts.
Analysis of a victim's remains from Herculaneum, a town destroyed by the Vesuvius eruption in 79 AD, revealed that the extreme heat of the pyroclastic flow vitrified the victim's brain tissue, turning it into a glassy substance. This is the first time this phenomenon has been observed in archaeological remains. The victim, believed to be a man in his 20s, was found lying face down on a wooden bed, likely killed instantly by the intense heat. The glassy material found in his skull, analyzed to be mostly fatty acids and human brain proteins, provides unique insight into the extreme temperatures reached during the eruption and their effects on human tissue.
HN commenters discuss the plausibility of the victim's brain vitrifying, with several expressing skepticism due to the required temperatures and rapid cooling. Some point out that other organic materials like wood don't typically vitrify in these circumstances, and question the lack of similar findings in other Vesuvius victims. One commenter with experience in glass production notes the differences between natural glass formation (like obsidian) and the creation of glass from organic matter. Others discuss the ethics of displaying human remains and the potential for further research to confirm or refute the vitrification claim. Some commenters also highlight the gruesome yet fascinating nature of the discovery and the unique glimpse it provides into the destruction of Pompeii.
Summary of Comments ( 1 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43213563
Hacker News users discuss the ethical implications of the accidental creation of a glassy material from a human brain during routine cremation preparations. Several question the lack of informed consent, particularly since the unusual formation might hold scientific value. Commenters also debate the legal ownership of such a material and express concerns about the potential for future exploitation in similar situations. Some are skeptical of the "accidental" nature, suggesting the preparation deviated from standard procedure, potentially hinting at undiscussed elements of the process. The scientific value of the glassy material is also a point of contention, with some arguing for further research and others dismissing it as an interesting but ultimately unimportant anomaly. A few commenters provide technical insights into the potential mechanisms behind the vitrification, focusing on the high temperatures and phosphate content.
The Hacker News post "Formation of organic glass from a human brain" (linking to a Nature article about vitrified brain tissue found in victims of the Herculaneum eruption) spawned a moderate discussion with several interesting threads.
Many commenters focused on the incredible preservation offered by the vitrification process. One user highlighted the rarity and scientific value of such a discovery, emphasizing how unusual it is to find preserved brain tissue from that period, let alone in a vitrified state that could potentially hold more detailed information. Another expressed astonishment at the preservation of neural structures, pondering the implications for future studies of ancient brains. The implications for understanding the nervous system and its evolution over time were a recurring theme, with some speculating on the possibility of extracting meaningful information from such well-preserved tissue.
A couple of commenters discussed the specifics of the vitrification process, mentioning the rapid heating and cooling involved, and comparing it to similar processes in other materials like glass. One user with expertise in glass formation chimed in, explaining how the high temperatures involved in the eruption would likely have caused the rapid dehydration and vitrification of the brain tissue.
Several comments centered on the ethical considerations of studying human remains, especially in such a unique and sensitive context. One commenter wondered about the ethical guidelines involved in studying remains from such a disaster, particularly regarding respect for the deceased and their descendants. Another questioned the potential for sensationalism and exploitation in such studies, urging caution and sensitivity.
Some users offered insightful connections to other fields, such as archaeology and materials science. One commenter drew parallels to the preservation of organic matter in amber, highlighting the different mechanisms but similar outcomes in terms of long-term preservation. Another linked the discussion to recent advances in cryopreservation and the potential for future applications based on similar principles.
Finally, there was a brief discussion about the title of the Hacker News post, with one commenter suggesting it could be slightly misleading as it implies the entire brain was vitrified, while the article discusses a smaller section of brain tissue.
Overall, the comments section reflected a mixture of awe at the scientific discovery, curiosity about the process and its implications, and ethical considerations surrounding the study of ancient human remains.