Stories with Tag curriculum

• A Math Lesson From Hitler’s Germany (2017)

  permalink

  Posted: 2025-04-18 13:55:50

  Verbose tl;dr

  This article explores how mathematics, specifically statistics and probability, were manipulated in Nazi Germany to promote racist ideologies and justify discriminatory policies. It examines how seemingly objective mathematical concepts were twisted and selectively applied to create a false sense of scientific backing for eugenic programs and the persecution of minorities. By focusing on skewed data and misrepresenting statistical concepts, the Nazi regime aimed to convince the public of the inferiority of certain groups, thereby normalizing and legitimizing their horrific actions. The article serves as a warning about the potential for mathematical tools to be misused in the service of dangerous ideologies.

  Michael J. Barany's 2017 Undark Magazine article, "A Math Lesson From Hitler’s Germany," delves into the complex and often paradoxical relationship between mathematics, politics, and ideology during the Nazi regime. Rather than portraying a simplistic narrative of intellectual suppression, Barany illustrates the nuanced ways in which mathematics was both instrumentalized and contested within the Third Reich. He focuses on the career and experiences of Ludwig Bieberbach, a prominent mathematician known for his contributions to complex analysis and geometry, who became an ardent supporter of National Socialism. Bieberbach attempted to establish what he termed "Deutsche Mathematik," or German mathematics, a racially inflected approach to the discipline that sought to distinguish itself from what he perceived as the overly abstract and "Jewish" nature of modern mathematics.

  Barany meticulously details Bieberbach’s efforts to align mathematics with Nazi ideology, including his attempts to infuse racial theories into mathematical pedagogy and research. Bieberbach promoted the idea that different races possessed inherent mathematical styles, arguing that "German" mathematics was intuitive, visual, and grounded in physical reality, while "Jewish" mathematics was overly abstract, formalistic, and detached from the real world. He used these purported distinctions to justify the exclusion and persecution of Jewish mathematicians from German universities and academic societies.

  The article further explores the reactions and resistance to Bieberbach’s ideological project within the mathematical community. While some mathematicians embraced or passively accepted Deutsche Mathematik, others actively opposed it, arguing that mathematics was a universal and objective discipline transcending racial and political boundaries. Barany highlights the debates and controversies that arose surrounding this issue, demonstrating that the mathematical landscape of Nazi Germany was not monolithic but characterized by a complex interplay of conformity, dissent, and opportunistic maneuvering.

  Barany’s analysis extends beyond the purely intellectual realm to examine the practical implications of Deutsche Mathematik. He discusses how these ideologically driven pronouncements impacted the careers and lives of mathematicians, both Jewish and non-Jewish, affecting hiring decisions, research funding, and the overall direction of mathematical inquiry in Germany. The article also touches on the international ramifications of this politicization of mathematics, illustrating how it influenced collaborations and exchanges between German mathematicians and their colleagues in other countries.

  In conclusion, "A Math Lesson From Hitler’s Germany" offers a nuanced and historically grounded exploration of the entanglement of mathematics with Nazi ideology. It underscores the dangers of politicizing scientific disciplines and highlights the importance of upholding the principles of intellectual freedom and objectivity in the face of ideological pressures. Barany’s meticulous research and detailed narrative shed light on a complex and often overlooked chapter in the history of mathematics, providing valuable insights into the interplay between science, politics, and ideology in a time of profound social and political upheaval.

  • World War II
  • Nazi Germany
  • mathematics
  • Education
  • History
  • Propaganda
  • Indoctrination
  • Eugenics
  • Racial Ideology
  • Nationalism
  • Germany
  • 1930s
  • curriculum
  • Political Science
  • Social Studies

  Summary of Comments ( 12 )
  https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43728130

  Verbose tl;dr

  Hacker News users discuss the role of mathematics in Nazi Germany, focusing on how mathematical skill and logic were twisted to serve a hateful ideology. Some commenters point out the danger of believing that intelligence or technical proficiency inherently leads to morality, highlighting how easily logic can be applied to justify horrific acts. Others discuss the specific examples in the article, like Bieberbach's attempts to define "German mathematics" and the expulsion of Jewish mathematicians, illustrating the devastating impact of such politicization. Several users express concern about the potential for similar abuses of science and reason in the present day, warning against complacency. There's also a brief thread on the general difficulty of defining "national" characteristics in fields like mathematics, with some arguing that it's inherently a universal pursuit.

  The Hacker News post titled "A Math Lesson From Hitler’s Germany (2017)" has a modest number of comments, sparking a discussion around the role of mathematics in a politically charged environment. Several commenters engage with the historical context presented in the article.

  One commenter highlights the chilling anecdote from the article about a Jewish mathematician being forced to teach "Jewish mathematics" as a form of humiliation and persecution. This comment emphasizes the perversion of mathematics for ideological purposes and the cruelty inflicted upon intellectuals during the Nazi regime.

  Another commenter draws a parallel between the historical context of the article and contemporary issues, pointing out the dangers of politicizing science and mathematics. They argue that manipulating scientific principles for political gain can have detrimental consequences, echoing the misuse of mathematics described in the article.

  A different thread of discussion focuses on the nature of mathematics itself. One commenter questions the very premise of "Jewish mathematics," asserting that mathematics is a universal language and cannot be categorized by ethnicity or ideology. This perspective reinforces the idea that mathematics exists independently of political or social constructs.

  A further comment expands on this by exploring the concept of "German physics," another example of attempting to align scientific fields with nationalistic ideologies. They highlight the absurdity of such endeavors, emphasizing the universality and objectivity of scientific principles.

  Several comments offer additional historical context, referencing other instances of science and mathematics being manipulated for political purposes throughout history. These examples serve to underscore the recurring nature of this phenomenon and the importance of safeguarding intellectual pursuits from ideological influence.

  While the number of comments isn't extensive, the discussion offers a valuable reflection on the intersection of mathematics, politics, and history. The commenters collectively express concern about the dangers of politicizing science and highlight the importance of upholding the integrity of intellectual disciplines.

• The Mensa Reading List for Grades 9-12

  permalink

  Posted: 2025-04-06 13:08:32

  Verbose tl;dr

  Mensa's recommended reading list for high school students offers a diverse range of classic and contemporary literature spanning various genres and cultures. The list emphasizes challenging texts that encourage critical thinking and expose students to different perspectives. Included are works of fiction, non-fiction, poetry, and drama, from authors like Shakespeare, Austen, Orwell, and Angelou, aiming to broaden literary horizons and foster a lifelong love of reading. The list is not exhaustive, but rather a starting point for exploring the rich world of literature.

  This Substack post, entitled "The Mensa Reading List for Grades 9-12," presents a meticulously curated collection of literary works recommended by the high-IQ society Mensa for high school students. The author prefaces the list with an acknowledgement that such compilations are inherently subjective and can spark debate, particularly regarding the inclusion or exclusion of specific titles. They emphasize that the list should not be perceived as prescriptive but rather as a potential springboard for intellectual exploration and the discovery of new literary landscapes. Furthermore, the author explicitly states that the list's organization into grade levels shouldn't be construed as a rigid framework; students are encouraged to engage with the material at their own pace and according to their individual interests and maturity levels.

  The list itself is subdivided into four sections, corresponding to grades 9 through 12. Each grade level features a diverse assortment of genres, encompassing fiction, non-fiction, poetry, drama, and classic literature. Within each grade category, titles are arranged alphabetically by the author's last name, providing a structured, yet easily navigable presentation. The list encompasses a wide range of literary movements and historical periods, from ancient epics like Homer's The Odyssey to more contemporary works like The Joy Luck Club by Amy Tan. This breadth of selection aims to expose students to a variety of writing styles, themes, and perspectives, fostering a comprehensive understanding of the literary world.

  The author refrains from providing detailed summaries or critical analyses of the included works, focusing instead on presenting a concise and accessible list. This minimalist approach allows the titles to speak for themselves, inviting students to embark on their own literary journeys and form their individual interpretations. The overall impression is one of encouraging independent learning and a love of reading, offering a rich tapestry of literary possibilities for high school students seeking intellectual stimulation and enrichment. The implicit message is that this list serves not as a definitive guide but as a starting point for a lifelong exploration of the boundless world of literature.

  • Mensa
  • reading list
  • high school
  • Grades 9-12
  • Education
  • Literature
  • books
  • Recommended Reading
  • Academics
  • curriculum

  Summary of Comments ( 52 )
  https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43601190

  Verbose tl;dr

  HN commenters generally found the Mensa reading list unimpressive, criticizing it as uninspired, Eurocentric, and lacking diversity in both authors and genres. Several suggested alternative lists or resources, such as the Harold Bloom canon, "1001 Children’s Books You Must Read Before You Grow Up," and local library recommendations. Some commenters questioned the value of prescribed reading lists altogether, advocating instead for allowing students to explore their own interests. The lack of sci-fi/fantasy and more contemporary works was also a common complaint. A few defended the list, arguing that it provides a solid foundation in classic literature.

  The Hacker News post titled "The Mensa Reading List for Grades 9-12" linking to a Substack article about the same topic, generated a moderate amount of discussion with several commenters expressing skepticism and criticism of Mensa and the suggested reading list.

  One of the most compelling comments questioned the value and purpose of Mensa itself, suggesting it primarily serves as a way for members to validate their intelligence rather than fostering intellectual curiosity or engagement. This comment sparked a thread discussing the potential benefits and drawbacks of belonging to such organizations.

  Several commenters criticized the suggested reading list, finding it lacking in diversity and overly focused on Western literature. They argued for a more inclusive and representative selection of books that would expose students to a broader range of perspectives and cultural experiences. Specific examples of books that were deemed missing or better alternatives were offered, showcasing a desire for a more thoughtfully curated list.

  Another line of discussion centered on the relevance of standardized reading lists in general. Some commenters argued that personalized reading journeys are more effective than following a prescribed list, emphasizing the importance of individual interests and learning styles. They suggested that encouraging students to explore books they find genuinely engaging is more likely to cultivate a love of reading.

  There were also comments expressing concern over the lack of specific criteria used to compile the Mensa list. The absence of a clear rationale for the inclusion or exclusion of certain books left some commenters wondering about the underlying methodology and objectives of the list.

  Finally, a few commenters shared their personal experiences with Mensa and offered anecdotes about the organization's activities and culture. These comments provided some insight into the community aspect of Mensa, while also acknowledging its potential shortcomings.

• Schools reviving shop class

  permalink

  Posted: 2025-03-02 16:32:13

  Verbose tl;dr

  Facing a shortage of skilled tradespeople and a growing recognition of the value of hands-on learning, high schools across the U.S. are reviving shop classes. These modernized programs, often incorporating advanced technologies like robotics and 3D printing alongside traditional woodworking and metalworking, aim to equip students with practical skills applicable to various industries. The resurgence is driven by employer demand, student interest in alternatives to college, and a desire to foster problem-solving abilities and critical thinking. These revamped shop classes offer pathways to well-paying jobs directly after graduation or provide a foundation for further technical education.

  Across the United States, a discernible resurgence of vocational training programs, specifically those reminiscent of traditional "shop class," is taking place within secondary educational institutions. These programs, frequently rebranded with more contemporary nomenclature such as "career and technical education" (CTE), represent a pronounced shift away from the singular focus on college preparation that has dominated educational philosophy for the past several decades. This renewed emphasis on hands-on, skills-based learning arises from multiple converging factors.

  Firstly, a growing recognition pervades amongst educators, policymakers, and students alike that a four-year college degree is not the sole pathway to a fulfilling and financially secure future. The escalating costs of higher education coupled with the increasing burden of student loan debt have prompted a reevaluation of the perceived value proposition of a traditional bachelor's degree. Simultaneously, a significant skills gap has emerged within numerous industries, particularly in the trades, manufacturing, and technical fields. Employers are encountering difficulties in finding qualified candidates to fill these well-paying positions, highlighting the critical need for a workforce equipped with practical, applicable skills.

  In response to these evolving economic realities and labor market demands, high schools are actively reinvesting in vocational programs. These revitalized shop classes offer students the opportunity to acquire tangible skills in areas such as welding, machining, carpentry, automotive repair, and computer-aided design (CAD). Furthermore, many of these programs are incorporating elements of advanced manufacturing technologies, such as robotics and 3D printing, thereby preparing students for the increasingly sophisticated demands of modern industries.

  This resurgence is not merely a nostalgic return to the shop classes of yesteryear. Instead, it represents a deliberate and strategic effort to modernize vocational education, aligning it with the current and projected needs of the 21st-century economy. By providing students with a viable alternative to the conventional college track, these programs aim to equip them with the practical skills and knowledge necessary to secure gainful employment directly upon graduation or to pursue further specialized training through apprenticeships or technical colleges. This, in turn, serves to bolster the skilled workforce pipeline and contribute to the overall economic vitality of the nation. The evolving landscape of secondary education reflects a growing understanding of the importance of diverse educational pathways and the value of hands-on learning in preparing students for successful and productive futures.

  • shop class
  • vocational education
  • career and technical education
  • CTE
  • high school
  • Education
  • skills gap
  • manufacturing
  • trades
  • workforce development
  • labor market
  • students
  • curriculum
  • hands-on learning
  • applied learning

  Summary of Comments ( 62 )
  https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43232087

  Verbose tl;dr

  Hacker News users generally lauded the return of shop class, citing the value of hands-on learning, problem-solving skills, and exposure to trades. Several commenters shared personal anecdotes about how shop class positively influenced their career paths, even if they didn't pursue a trade directly. Some expressed concern about the cost and difficulty of implementing these programs effectively, including the need for qualified instructors and adequate safety measures. The importance of incorporating modern technology like CAD and 3D printing into shop curriculum was also discussed. A few commenters cautioned against viewing shop class as a solution for all students, emphasizing the need for diverse educational pathways. There was also some discussion of the societal shift away from valuing vocational skills and how its resurgence could address the current skilled labor shortage.

  The Hacker News post "Schools reviving shop class," linking to a Wall Street Journal article about the resurgence of shop classes, generated a significant number of comments discussing various facets of this trend.

  Many commenters expressed strong support for shop classes, emphasizing the value of hands-on learning and the development of practical skills. They argued that these classes provide a valuable alternative learning pathway for students who might not thrive in traditional academic settings. Several users shared personal anecdotes about how shop class positively impacted their lives and careers, even if they didn't pursue trades directly. The sentiment that these classes teach valuable problem-solving skills and a sense of accomplishment was prevalent. Some also highlighted the importance of shop class in fostering an appreciation for craftsmanship and the workings of the physical world.

  A recurring theme in the discussion was the perceived decline of shop classes in past decades and the societal factors that contributed to it. Some attributed the decline to an overemphasis on college preparation and a devaluation of vocational skills. Others pointed to budget cuts and shifting educational priorities. The current revival of shop class was seen as a positive corrective to these trends, reflecting a renewed recognition of the importance of trade skills and the need for a more diverse educational landscape.

  Several commenters discussed the practical aspects of implementing and sustaining shop programs. Concerns were raised about the costs of equipment and materials, the need for qualified instructors, and the challenges of integrating shop classes into existing curricula. Some suggested partnerships with local businesses and community organizations as a way to address these challenges. The importance of safety training and proper supervision was also emphasized.

  A few commenters offered more nuanced perspectives on the topic. Some cautioned against romanticizing shop class or viewing it as a panacea for all educational woes. They argued that a balanced approach is needed, one that values both academic and vocational skills. Others pointed out that the nature of shop class has evolved over time, with new technologies and manufacturing processes requiring updated curricula and equipment. The need for shop classes to adapt to the changing demands of the 21st-century workforce was a recurring point of discussion. Finally, some commenters linked the resurgence of shop class to broader trends like the maker movement and the growing interest in DIY culture.