The Portland Mercury article argues that Poison Idea, despite their volatile history and lack of mainstream recognition, are the greatest hardcore band of all time. The band's aggressive sound, confrontational lyrics reflecting their bleak Portland surroundings, and relentless touring cemented their influence on countless bands. Frontman Jerry A.'s outsized personality and struggles with addiction, while contributing to the band's instability, also added to their legend. The piece positions Poison Idea not just as a vital part of Portland's music scene, but as a crucial act in hardcore's evolution, inspiring generations with their raw power and uncompromising vision.
In a 2013 article for the Portland Mercury titled "Portland's Poisonous Past – Poison Idea Are Hardcore's Greatest of All Time," author Ned Lannamann meticulously constructs an argument for Poison Idea's enduring legacy and unparalleled influence within the hardcore punk genre. Lannamann's central thesis posits that the Portland-based band, despite operating largely outside the mainstream, deserves recognition as the most significant act in hardcore history. He meticulously deconstructs the band's impact, exploring their aggressive musical style, confrontational lyrical content, and uncompromising DIY ethos.
Lannamann delves deeply into the band's history, beginning with their formation in 1980 and tracing their evolution through various lineups and releases. He emphasizes the volatile brilliance of the late Jerry A., the band's iconic frontman, whose raw energy and unflinchingly honest lyrics served as the driving force behind Poison Idea's powerful message. Lannamann underscores the band's distinct sound, characterized by a ferocious blend of punk rock velocity, heavy metal riffs, and a raw, untamed intensity that set them apart from their contemporaries. He argues that this sonic ferocity, coupled with Jerry A.'s deeply personal and often politically charged lyrics, contributed to the band's enduring appeal.
The article highlights the crucial role of the band's unwavering commitment to the DIY ethic, which manifested in self-releasing records, organizing their own tours, and fostering a strong connection with their fanbase. Lannamann argues that this independent spirit, combined with their uncompromising artistic vision, cemented Poison Idea's status as authentic and influential figures in the underground music scene. He meticulously catalogs their extensive discography, highlighting key albums like Kings of Punk, Feel the Darkness, and Pick Your King, and meticulously dissects their lyrical themes, which range from personal struggles with addiction and mental health to broader societal critiques.
Lannamann's analysis goes beyond simply praising the band's musical output. He delves into the socio-political context of the time, exploring how Poison Idea's music resonated with marginalized communities and provided a voice for the disenfranchised. He suggests that their raw honesty and unflinching portrayal of social realities made them a truly important force in hardcore punk, pushing boundaries and challenging conventions. Ultimately, Lannamann's comprehensive exploration of Poison Idea's history, musical style, and enduring impact serves to solidify his argument that they are, indeed, the greatest hardcore band of all time, a claim he supports with detailed evidence and passionate conviction.
Summary of Comments ( 0 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43171305
HN commenters discuss Portland's hardcore punk scene and Poison Idea's influence. Some debate the band's status as the "greatest of all time," with some suggesting other influential bands like Black Flag and Minor Threat. Others reminisce about seeing Poison Idea live, recalling their intense performances and Jerry A.'s powerful stage presence. Several commenters also touch upon the darker aspects of the band and the Portland scene, including drug use and violence, while acknowledging the band's significant contribution to hardcore punk. A few share personal anecdotes about encounters with band members and reflect on the evolution of the hardcore scene.
The Hacker News post linking the Portland Mercury article "Portland's Poisonous Past" has generated a modest number of comments, primarily focused on the band Poison Idea's influence, sound, and legacy. No one disputes the band's importance in the hardcore scene.
Several commenters reminisce about seeing Poison Idea perform live, emphasizing the intensity and chaotic energy of their shows. One commenter recalls seeing them open for Pantera and describes the experience as one of the best live shows they ever witnessed. Another details a particularly wild show involving pyrotechnics and general mayhem. These anecdotes highlight the band's reputation for powerful, often unruly performances.
There's discussion about Jerry A.'s (the band's frontman) weight and its impact on his health and stage presence, with some lamenting the decline in his physical condition over the years but acknowledging his enduring passion. The tragic nature of his later years is touched upon, with commenters expressing sadness at his eventual passing.
The musical aspects of Poison Idea are also discussed. Commenters praise the band's distinctive sound, describing it as a blend of hardcore punk, metal, and a "proto-sludge/grunge" element. Their "Kings of Punk" album is singled out for particular praise, with some calling it their best work. Others mention the band's evolution over time and appreciate their later material as well.
Some commenters delve into the Portland punk scene in general, noting the city's unique contribution to the genre and placing Poison Idea within that context. One commenter even mentions other Portland bands of the era, broadening the discussion beyond just Poison Idea.
While the overall volume of comments isn't extensive, they provide a mix of personal experiences, musical analysis, and historical context surrounding Poison Idea, painting a picture of a band that deeply impacted the hardcore punk scene and left a lasting impression on its fans.