The Substack post "Photographs of 19th Century Japan" showcases a curated collection of images offering a glimpse into life in Japan during the Meiji era and late Edo period. These photographs, many hand-colored, depict a range of subjects, from landscapes and cityscapes to portraits of individuals and scenes of daily life. The collection illustrates a period of significant transition in Japan, bridging the traditional world with the burgeoning influences of modernization. The curated imagery emphasizes the beauty and unique cultural aspects of Japan during this historical timeframe.
The Smithsonian Magazine is seeking help identifying a prolific yet unknown photographer who documented San Francisco street life in the 1960s. Thousands of color slides, discovered in a box at a flea market, offer vibrant snapshots of everyday life, fashion, architecture, and cars of the era. The photographer's identity remains a mystery, and the magazine hopes the public can help shed light on who this individual was and the story behind the remarkable collection.
Hacker News users discussed the mystery photographer's skill, noting the compelling composition and subject matter of the photos. Some speculated on the photographer's possible professional background, suggesting they might have been a photojournalist or worked in advertising given the quality and volume of images. Several commenters focused on the technical aspects, discussing the likely camera and film used, and the challenges of street photography in that era. Others shared personal connections to San Francisco in the 1960s, adding context and reminiscing about the city during that time. A few users also suggested strategies for identifying the photographer, such as examining photo metadata or contacting local historical societies. The overall sentiment was one of appreciation for the discovered photos and a desire to uncover the photographer's identity.
The Substack post "Photographs of the Old West" showcases a curated collection of historical images offering glimpses into life in the American West during the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The photographs, many by renowned photographers like William Henry Jackson and Edward Curtis, depict diverse subjects, from landscapes and indigenous peoples to frontier towns, cowboys, and the burgeoning railroad. The post emphasizes the romanticized perception of the West versus its complex realities, highlighting both the grandeur of the landscape and the hardships faced by those who inhabited it.
Hacker News users discussed the surprising modernity visible in the "Old West" photographs, noting the paved streets, electric lines, and fashionable clothing. Some commenters highlighted the staged nature of many iconic Western images, contrasting them with the more mundane reality depicted in these photos. The discussion also touched on the rapid technological advancement of the era, the relatively late closure of the frontier, and the romanticized perception of the Old West perpetuated by Hollywood. Several commenters shared additional resources, including links to other photo collections and historical information. A few questioned the accuracy of the "Old West" designation for some of the later photographs, pointing out that they depict a period closer to the early 20th century.
Summary of Comments ( 110 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43631251
Hacker News users discuss the captivating nature of the linked photographs, appreciating the glimpse into everyday life in 19th-century Japan. Several commenters express fascination with the clothing and hairstyles depicted, with some noting the apparent mix of traditional Japanese and Western styles. The quality of the photographs, especially considering their age, is also a point of admiration. One commenter points out the poignancy of these images, representing people who lived entirely different lives, yet shared the same human experience. A few users share links to related resources, including other collections of historical Japanese photographs and information on the photographic techniques of the time.
The Hacker News post titled "Photographs of 19th Century Japan" linking to a Cosmographia Substack article has generated several comments. Many users express appreciation for the photographs and the glimpse they offer into a bygone era.
One commenter points out the stark contrast between the traditional Japanese clothing and architecture and the occasional appearance of Western-style attire, highlighting the period of cultural transition Japan was undergoing at the time. They note this juxtaposition evokes a sense of "melancholy beauty," reflecting the fading traditional ways of life as modernization took hold.
Another commenter picks up on this theme, observing the transition visible in the photos, specifically mentioning the shift from traditional Japanese topknot hairstyles to more Westernized haircuts. This visual cue further emphasizes the societal changes documented in the imagery.
Several commenters discuss the photographic processes used in the 19th century, appreciating the artistry and technical skill involved in capturing these images. One comment specifically mentions the collodion process, likely used for some of these photos, and notes the unique aesthetic qualities it imparts.
Another user expresses fascination with the Kusakabe Kimbei hand-colored photographs, praising their vividness and the way they capture the atmosphere of the time. This commenter also highlights the historical significance of these photographs, showcasing a world on the cusp of major transformation.
A few commenters share additional resources, including links to other collections of 19th-century Japanese photography and related historical information, further enriching the discussion. One such link directs to a collection of Felice Beato's photographs, another prominent photographer of 19th-century Japan.
Overall, the comments on the Hacker News post reflect a deep appreciation for the historical and artistic value of the photographs. They discuss the technical aspects of 19th-century photography, the cultural transitions evident in the images, and the beauty of the captured moments. The commenters also contribute additional context and resources, making the discussion more informative and engaging.