Bruno Postle's "Piranesi's Perspective Trick" explores how 18th-century Italian artist Giovanni Battista Piranesi created the illusion of vast, impossible spaces in his etchings. Piranesi achieved this not through complex mathematical perspective but by subtly shifting the vanishing points and manipulating the scale of elements within a scene. By strategically placing smaller figures and architectural details in the foreground against exaggeratedly large background elements, and by employing multiple, inconsistent vanishing points, Piranesi generated a sense of immense depth and disorienting grandeur that transcends traditional perspective rules. This artistic sleight-of-hand contributes to the dreamlike and often unsettling atmosphere of his famous "Carceri" (Prisons) series and other works.
VietGD.com showcases Vietnamese graphic design, aiming to document and promote the country's evolving visual identity. The site features a curated collection of work spanning various disciplines, including branding, typography, illustration, and packaging design, from both established and emerging Vietnamese creatives. It highlights the unique blend of traditional Vietnamese aesthetics and modern design influences present in the showcased work, offering a comprehensive overview of the current graphic design landscape in Vietnam.
Hacker News users discuss the unique aesthetic of Vietnamese graphic design showcased on vietgd.com, noting its vibrant colors, bold typography, and occasional "maximalist" approach that contrasts with Western minimalist design trends. Some commenters draw parallels to Chinese and Korean graphic design, highlighting shared cultural influences and a preference for ornamentation. Others appreciate the website's organization and the historical context provided. A few express interest in learning more about Vietnamese design principles and the cultural context that shapes these aesthetics. Some users critique the site's English translation and suggest improvements. Overall, the comments reflect a positive reception of the website and a genuine curiosity about Vietnamese graphic design.
Summary of Comments ( 68 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43492562
Commenters on Hacker News largely discussed the plausibility and effectiveness of Piranesi's supposed perspective trick, as described in the Medium article. Some debated whether the "trick" was intentional or simply a result of his artistic style and the limitations of etching. One commenter suggested Piranesi's unique perspective contributes to the unsettling and dreamlike atmosphere of his works, rather than being a deliberate deception. Others pointed out that the described "trick" is a common technique in perspective drawing, particularly in stage design, to exaggerate depth and create a sense of grandeur. Several commenters also shared links to other analyses of Piranesi's work and the mathematics of perspective. A few expressed appreciation for the article introducing them to Piranesi's art.
The Hacker News post titled "Piranesi's Perspective Trick (2019)" has several comments discussing the article about how Piranesi created his impossible architectural drawings. Many commenters focus on the intentional ambiguity and dreamlike quality of Piranesi's work.
One commenter highlights the role of capriccio, a genre of art emphasizing fantasy and imagination, in understanding Piranesi's work. They suggest Piranesi wasn't necessarily trying to depict realistically possible structures, but rather exploring imaginative architectural spaces. This resonates with another commenter who notes Piranesi's influence on fantasy and science fiction, suggesting his work evokes a sense of awe and wonder at impossible structures, rather than a strict adherence to architectural realism.
Another commenter draws a parallel between Piranesi's work and M.C. Escher's, pointing out the shared interest in manipulating perspective and creating illusions. They propose both artists explore the boundaries of what is visually conceivable, even if physically impossible.
A significant point of discussion centers around the actual "trick" Piranesi employed. While the article suggests a specific method, some commenters propose alternative techniques Piranesi might have used. One commenter, for instance, suggests the use of multiple vanishing points, a technique common in pre-Renaissance art, might have contributed to the disorienting and expansive feel of his etchings. Another commenter speculates about the use of distorted grids and manipulated perspective lines, emphasizing the deliberate nature of the illusions Piranesi created.
Further comments discuss the potential influence of stage design on Piranesi's work. The commenter posits that techniques used to create the illusion of depth and grandeur on a stage could have informed Piranesi's approach to depicting architecture.
Overall, the comments reflect a fascination with the technical skill and artistic vision behind Piranesi's work. The discussion explores not only the "trick" itself, but also the broader context of capriccio, the influence on later artists like Escher, and the various techniques that might have contributed to Piranesi's unique and enduring style. They emphasize the deliberate artistic choices Piranesi made to evoke a sense of wonder and explore the boundaries of architectural representation.