BMW Group Classic's "Historic Models" page provides a comprehensive overview of BMW's automotive history, showcasing the evolution of its vehicles from the pre-war era to the present day. Organized chronologically, the site features detailed profiles of each model series, highlighting key design features, technical innovations, and historical context. Users can explore the heritage of iconic models like the 328, Isetta, and M1, as well as lesser-known vehicles that contributed to BMW's legacy. The catalog allows enthusiasts and researchers to delve into the rich history of the brand, tracing its progression from aircraft engine manufacturer to a global leader in premium automobiles.
Tesla is recalling nearly 380,000 vehicles in the US due to a power steering assist fault. The recall affects Model S and X vehicles from 2017-2023, specifically those equipped with full self-driving (FSD) Beta software or pending installation. The issue can cause the power steering to intermittently fail, especially at low speeds or after hitting a bump, requiring increased steering effort and potentially increasing the risk of a crash. An over-the-air software update will address the problem.
HN commenters discuss the vagueness of the recall notice, questioning whether it's a software or hardware issue, and how a software update could resolve a "loss of power steering assist." Some express skepticism about Tesla's reliance on over-the-air updates for safety-critical systems, noting the potential for unforeseen software bugs. Others point out the increasing frequency of Tesla recalls and question the robustness of their initial quality control. A few commenters share personal anecdotes of similar issues with their Teslas, highlighting concerns about safety and the inconvenience of these recurring problems. Some also mention the potential impact on Tesla's reputation and the broader implications for the autonomous driving industry.
Summary of Comments ( 42 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43223930
HN users generally expressed appreciation for the comprehensive and well-organized nature of BMW's historical model catalog. Several pointed out the usefulness of the chassis code search functionality. Some commenters reminisced about their personal experiences with specific BMW models, while others discussed the evolution of BMW design and engineering over time. A few users highlighted interesting details found within the catalog, such as the inclusion of motorcycles and aircraft engines. There was also discussion about BMW's branding and marketing, with some questioning the company's current direction.
The Hacker News post titled "BMW Group Product Catalog–Historic Models" linking to BMW's historical model overview sparked a small but focused discussion, primarily revolving around the usability and completeness of the catalog itself.
One commenter expressed disappointment with the catalog, noting its lack of comprehensive information and poor organization. They specifically wished for more details, lamenting that it was "just pictures" and desired more technical specifications, historical context, and production figures for each model. They felt the catalog fell short of their expectations for a resource purporting to be a historical overview.
Another commenter echoed this sentiment, finding the catalog "disappointing" and "shallow." They specifically contrasted it unfavorably to Mercedes-Benz's equivalent offering, praising the latter's detailed engine information and downloadable brochures. They highlighted how the BMW catalog, in their view, provided a superficial overview with limited details.
A third commenter focused on the user experience, criticizing the website's implementation as a single, long page. They expressed a preference for a more structured, multi-page approach, allowing for easier navigation and exploration of the different models. They specifically mentioned the difficulty of navigating such a long page and finding specific information within it.
Beyond these criticisms of the catalog itself, one commenter shared an anecdote about encountering a rare BMW Isetta bubble car in their youth, triggered by seeing it listed in the catalog. While not directly related to the catalog's quality, this comment added a personal touch to the discussion, reflecting the nostalgic appeal of classic cars.
In summary, the comments on the Hacker News post largely centered on the shortcomings of the BMW historical model catalog. Commenters consistently expressed their disappointment with its lack of depth, missing technical details, and cumbersome single-page design, particularly when compared to other manufacturers' offerings. A personal anecdote added a human element to the otherwise technical critique.