Analysis of a victim's remains from Herculaneum, a town destroyed by the Vesuvius eruption in 79 AD, revealed that the extreme heat of the pyroclastic flow vitrified the victim's brain tissue, turning it into a glassy substance. This is the first time this phenomenon has been observed in archaeological remains. The victim, believed to be a man in his 20s, was found lying face down on a wooden bed, likely killed instantly by the intense heat. The glassy material found in his skull, analyzed to be mostly fatty acids and human brain proteins, provides unique insight into the extreme temperatures reached during the eruption and their effects on human tissue.
In a macabre yet scientifically fascinating discovery, researchers studying the remnants of the catastrophic eruption of Mount Vesuvius in 79 AD have unearthed evidence of an unprecedented phenomenon: vitrification of brain tissue. The eruption, infamous for burying the Roman cities of Pompeii and Herculaneum under volcanic ash and pyroclastic flows, claimed thousands of lives. This latest finding, originating from the archaeological site of Herculaneum and detailed in the New England Journal of Medicine, focuses on the remains of a young man, believed to be in his mid-twenties, discovered in the 1960s within the Collegium Augustalium, a building dedicated to the imperial cult.
While previous studies have identified skeletal remains and even partially preserved soft tissues at Herculaneum, this particular case presents a truly exceptional occurrence. The intense heat generated by the pyroclastic surge, a rapidly moving current of hot gas and volcanic debris, is postulated to have caused the victim's brain tissue to undergo vitrification, a process where organic material is transformed into a glassy substance. This process, akin to the formation of obsidian from molten rock, is exceptionally rare in archaeological contexts. The presence of glassy material within the victim's skull, identified through microscopic analysis and confirmed to contain proteins and fatty acids characteristic of brain tissue, provides compelling evidence for this extraordinary transformation.
The researchers hypothesize that the extreme heat, estimated to have reached temperatures as high as 520 degrees Celsius, rapidly vaporized the victim's bodily fluids, creating an oxygen-deprived environment within the skull. This anoxic environment, combined with the intense heat, facilitated the vitrification process, essentially preserving the brain tissue in a glassy state for centuries. The preservation of such delicate organic material within the context of such a violent and destructive event provides invaluable insights into the extreme conditions experienced by the inhabitants of Herculaneum during the eruption and highlights the unique preservational properties of pyroclastic flows. Furthermore, the discovery sheds light on the destructive power of volcanic eruptions and contributes significantly to our understanding of the taphonomic processes involved in the preservation of human remains in such catastrophic events. This unprecedented find underscores the continuing potential for archaeological discoveries to enhance our comprehension of the past, even in sites that have been extensively studied for centuries.
Summary of Comments ( 63 )
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43196488
HN commenters discuss the plausibility of the victim's brain vitrifying, with several expressing skepticism due to the required temperatures and rapid cooling. Some point out that other organic materials like wood don't typically vitrify in these circumstances, and question the lack of similar findings in other Vesuvius victims. One commenter with experience in glass production notes the differences between natural glass formation (like obsidian) and the creation of glass from organic matter. Others discuss the ethics of displaying human remains and the potential for further research to confirm or refute the vitrification claim. Some commenters also highlight the gruesome yet fascinating nature of the discovery and the unique glimpse it provides into the destruction of Pompeii.
The Hacker News post "Man's brain turned to glass by hot Vesuvius ash cloud" has several comments discussing the BBC article about the discovery.
Many commenters focus on the fascinating and gruesome nature of vitrification, the process by which the victim's brain tissue was turned into a glassy substance. Several express astonishment at the intense heat and rapid process required for such a transformation to occur, pondering the agonizing final moments the victim must have experienced. Some question the specific mechanisms involved and debate whether the vitrification was caused by direct exposure to heat or some other process related to the pyroclastic flow.
Some commenters delve deeper into the scientific aspects of the discovery. They discuss the implications for understanding the eruption of Vesuvius and the conditions that existed in Herculaneum at the time. They also discuss the significance of the discovery in the context of archaeological research and the preservation of ancient remains. Several share links to additional resources and scientific papers that provide more detailed information on vitrification and the eruption of Vesuvius.
A few commenters express a morbid fascination with the details, while others approach the topic with a sense of reverence and respect for the victim and the historical context. Some discuss the ethical implications of studying such remains and the importance of handling them with sensitivity.
A thread develops around the differences between the destruction of Pompeii and Herculaneum, with commenters highlighting how the pyroclastic flows affected Herculaneum differently and contributed to the unique preservation of organic materials, including this victim's brain.
There's also some discussion about the challenges of accurately reconstructing historical events based on limited archaeological evidence. Commenters acknowledge the difficulty of definitively determining the exact sequence of events and the conditions that led to the victim's death.
Overall, the comments reflect a mix of awe, scientific curiosity, and respectful reflection on a remarkable archaeological discovery. The commenters engage in informed discussion, share relevant information, and express a range of perspectives on the implications of the findings.